Letters to the Editor
Letters to the Editor - 2024

Letter - Richard Tyler - Feb 2024
Keeping positive and hopeful as the loss of our countryside knocks on the door
Community has been an excellent initiative to bring together those living in the Woodstock and Bladon area, and I am proud to say that I am a subscriber.
As such, I am disappointed that the Editor has added further fuel to the already heated debate over the merits of the Botley West solar power station.
In the last edition of Community, the Editor made the serious allegation that the local volunteers trying to mitigate what they see as the negative impact of the project in its current form were spreading 'misinformation'. 'It smacks of blatant propaganda of the lowest sort to me!' the Editor wrote, accusing neighbours of Putin-like manipulation Community's Editor asks for the provenance of the statistic appearing on the flyers distributed by local volunteers that '80%' of local people oppose the power station. The statistic comes from the first official consultation by the developers of the power station and is available on their website. The developer asked the questions and reported the findings.
Some more facts: the idealistic portrayal of what the proposed solar power station will look like on p.21 of the last edition of Community skirted over the developer's plans to install 2 million panels, 156 threemetre-high secondary electricity transformers, and 6 six-metre high main transformers. This imagined rural idyll will be enclosed with 2 meter high security fencing, CCTV and infrared sensors.
All this information is publicly available in the developer's plan, and reiterated in the recent public consultation where its representatives made very clear that the choice of land to be developed for the power station was entirely down to the discretion of Blenheim Palace.
The power station will take two years to build, with a provisional start date of the autumn of 2025, with contractors working six days a week, from 7am to 7pm, with some night time drilling. During this twoyear period there will be heavy HGV traffic, and some local lanes will be temporarily closed, as will public footpaths across the site, which is larger in size than Heathrow Airport and includes areas of land that are classed as the highest quality agricultural grade.
The power station will emit the equivalent of 1.9 million tonnes of CO2 to construct (the average person in Britain creates around 10 tonnes of CO2 emissions each year). The developer estimates that operating the panels for c.40 years will save between 617,826 tonnes and 5.7 million tonnes of CO2 (compared with carrying on as we are) The developer's report also highlights how our area has seen above average increases in population growth over the last ten years as people are drawn to live and work here in our beautiful town and rural communities (12.7% growth compared with 7.5% for the south east of England as a whole in the same period). The rural landscape is a valuable amenity; it is short sighted to replace it with an industrial landscape.
As Hilary Brown from Sustainable Woodstock notes in her letter published in the same edition of Community there is still time to influence the developer's plans. Making our feelings known makes a difference: one of the land owners in the consortium, Merton College, has abandoned the power station project after deciding it can improve the biodiversity of its land in a more effective way.
Vague talk in the consultation of discounted electricity for affected communities needs to be clarified (a miserly 10% discount was mentioned by one of the developer's representatives at the public consultation event in Woodstock before Christmas). Communities in others countries living close to energy assets of national significance are compensated with far more generous discounts than that.
As with all issues, the debate for and against the power station is more nuanced than the Editor suggests. I am against the scheme as proposed as I feel strongly that it needs to be scaled back to something more proportionate, given the density of people living in our area.
However, our planning system forces people to choose sides, in an all or nothing battle. It ignores wishful thinking, uttered on the side lines.
So we should have an open debate, as friends and neighbours. And we should avoid the careless spread of misinformation, as expressed by the Editor, which only helps to shut down debate. Many thanks for publishing my letter.
Richard Tyler, Bladon
Letter - Hilary Brown - Feb 2024
Dear Editor, In December's issue of this magazine, I couldn't help but notice your editorial where you boldly questioned the flyer posted to every household. The red flyer stated '80% of local people oppose Botley West'. I had read the developer's report sometime before and couldn't remember the 80% flgure, and like you, I was also taken aback by the claim .. and so prompted to revisit the report.
Out of 22,000 documents delivered to homes in our area, the developers received just over 1000 responses. Of these 1000 responses, 80% opposed Botley West. In effect, this represented opposition from less than 4% of the homes contacted (assuming there was 1 reply per household).
I'm not a marketing specialist but know that numbers work very well with our brains ... and headline numbers work even better. Our brains are wired instinctively to understand that ‘more' usually equals ‘better'. So, numbers quickly and very effectively influence our thinking and can lead to instant engagement ... but when we don't have context or further information, numbers can be also misleading and lead to inaccurate and sometimes a wrong conclusion. In my opinion, given the context and the very low response ... the numbers on this flyer were not as clearly presented as they might have been ... were misleading and unfairly trying to influence residents' opinion on the proposed Botley West Solar Farm
Hilary Brown
Letter - Professor Alex Rogers - Feb 2024
Dear Editor,
We, like many of your readers, were taken aback by your editorial in the December issue in which you insinuated that the Stop Botley West campaign had fabricated data on the level of local opposition to the Botley West Solar Farm proposal. You said the statistic quoted in our leaflet (80% of local people are opposed) 'seems to be … misinformation' and 'It smacks of blatant propaganda of the lowest sort to me'' In fact the data was taken from the solar farm developer's consultation report which said 71% of respondents were strongly opposed and 9% were opposed (page 7, Botley West Phase One Consultation Summary Report https:// botleywest.co.uk/flles/cto_layout/img/documents/ Botley%20West%20Solar%20Farm%20CSR.pdf ) We wrote to you to point this out about this and you replied ‘I can see that I perhaps owe you an apology' and ‘I will mention this lack of understanding on my part in my next editorial'. We have not had sight of your February issue at the time of writing of course but trust it will include an apology from you.
The figure of 80% of people opposed refers to those who responded to the developer's consultation. You and your friends at Sustainable Woodstock have since suggested that the 4.94% of households that responded are too small a sample to respect local opinion and that it could be assumed that the 95% of people who did not respond are happy with the solar farm proposal.
Unfortunately this is another misunderstanding, this time of survey methodology and statistics. Firstly the 1,083 responses submitted to the first Botley West consultation in fact constitute an excellent sample; secondly it is very unwise to make any assumptions about the views of people who do not respond to a survey It is often said that the first casualty of war is the truth. Sadly the Botley West proposal has ignited conflict in our community. There are strong feelings on all sides but we should nonetheless try to have a respectful, evidence-based debate.
Professor Alex Rogers Chair, Stop Botley West Campaign
Letter - Dominic Hare - Apr 2024
Dear Editor,
Thank you to everyone who took part in both consultations for the proposed Botley West project. Every piece of feedback you provided is recorded and forms a vital part of shaping the proposal as it moves towards a DCO submission later this year. If you didn't get the chance to look at the proposal during the consultation period, please take a look on the Botley West website where the documents are, or keep an eye on how you can take part in the examination stages of the process.
The Development Consent process might seem cumbersome to those of us who do not interact with it every day but it is designed to mean that every project which makes it through is subject to the highest level of scrutiny with representations both for and against coming from both professionals and communities who would like to have their say.
For that reason, it is disappointing to continue seeing misguided narratives around the project and we encourage anyone to refer to latest data as it emerges from the process - this includes the latest Agricultural Land Classification.
Some of you will know that the only land data available prior to the extensive ground surveys which are now underway is that held by Natural England and that dataset is largely desktop based, dating back some decades. It's a good yardstick for all early stage projects until more detailed surveys are completed and based on that data the majority of the land promoted for Botley West fell outside of Best and Most Versatile (3b or lower). This aligns totally with knowledge from people who have cared for the land over decades.
As the ground is surveyed you would expect that some of the land is higher classification, some lower, and the developer is making no secret about that through the emerging documents and the emerging shape of the scheme Where pockets of different soil type exist, you have to take a practical approach to designing a scheme and this is consistent with other consented schemes across the UK, some of which are on higher quality land than exists here in West Oxfordshire.
The developer is also gaining greater understanding of the soil quality where, in the most recent harvest, almost all the crops grown on the land were at least 10% lower than national averages, in some areas significantly less than that, despite the very best care and inputs from farmers. It's also helpful to know that the vast majority of these crops were destined for animal feed or energy generation. This is the case with most UK Agriculture and reflects the asks we all make of our food chain today.
There is absolutely no question that, once rested under panels, the ground will immediately begin to recover. The concept of setting land aside and rotating crops for soil health in farming are something which date back centuries Once rested and not disturbed the soil begins rapidly to lock up carbon from the atmosphere and, after the life of the project, will come back into use totally regenerated and in doing so will have contributed our most critical need to decarbonise the energy we all rely on today. The positive impact on our biodiverse ecosystem from this project will also be very positive indeed.
Please keep an eye on the website as the shape of the proposal continues to emerge - particularly some of the very significant community benefits which you have all contributed to shaping.
Kind regards
Dominic Hare CEO, Blenheim
Letter - Aidan Salter - May 2024
Dear Editor,
Thank you for your support by making people aware of our last talk to raise funds for the Woodstock Exhibition Foundation. That talk and our coffee morning plus the investments we have, enabled us to provide 16 grants to local young people attending further education or apprenticeships totalling nearly £9600.
The next talk for fundraising is 'Man not the myth: Aspects of Churchill's character and personality on 8th July 2024 in St Mary Magdalene at 7.30 pm being given by Ashley Jackson who lives in Woodstock and is Professor of Imperial and Military History, Defence Studies Department, King's College London and also Visiting Fellow, Kellogg College Oxford.
Kind regards
Aidan Salter
Letter - Stan Scott - May 2024
Dear Editor,
A new Town Council.
We will soon have a new Woodstock Town Council. No election is needed, as only 11 people put up for the council this time, someone else can join later to complete the 12 people needed.
Big changes will come about, with some old faces, some new, some unexpected. A full list (still called nominations until all is official) can be seen at: www.westoxon.gov.uk/media/iwam0q2r/statement-ofpersons-nominatedparishcouncil-elections-2024.pdf
A few are returnees, either from the existing Council or from recent years, another from many years gone by, and several brand new. This should provide a very promising mix of experience and knowledge, particularly about rules, policies and past mistakes, and a fresh perspective of a kind, caring representation of local people.
There will be no place, we hope, for part-political interests and ambitions to impress elsewhere than in Woodstock Personally, I have never quite understood those who can wholeheartedly serve on our Town Council, where there is no place whatsoever for party political influences, and also serve on the District or County Council where party politics are everything. Such a councillor recently said at one of the meetings: 'The trouble is, you've asked a question of me as a County Councillor when I am here at your Town Council as a District Councillor.' I laughed at how ridiculous that sounded, but no one else did. This is a tricky division of loyalties which I hope that our political councillors can meet.
We really hope, do we not, for a return to the outlook of town councillors from years past, interested in what local people think, interested in finding out and representing local feeling, standing up for us all and fighting our corner if needs be. Could we ever again see our councillors out and about at weekends, asking folk what they think and what worries them? Alternatively, does something happen to appointed councillors as they walk through the Town Hall doors, that they now know what is best for us and can decide for us without needing to talk to us? Now, the Town Hall could again become a civilised debating chamber, well-managed and productive. We hope for a chairperson (always the Mayor, whoever that is voted to be by colleagues) who does not tell fellow councillors (and sometimes members of the public) to shut up or be quiet, but who can pick up and enlarge upon any point being made by any councillor, even if disagreeing with it, share it briefly and fairly with others, and invite further comment and call a vote if necessary.
Anyway, good luck to them all, from 7 May onwards, and a word for those who have now left. Some appeared to have party-political and personal motivations that interfered with their job of representation. However, others worked extremely hard during their period of office and had real potential for sound and long-serving public office, had infighting and cliques not got in the way. Our thanks and good wishes must go to them.
Our Town Council is a proud institution, and all we have by way of local democracy. I think that councillors deserve our interest, support and occasional comment to remind them that we are there.
Stan Scott
Letter - Anthony Glees - May 2024
Dear Editor,
It would be a shame if the regrettable decision of our best Town Councillors not to seek re-election in May were to pass by without comment. The outgoing Mayor, Nick Manby-Brown, Jo Lamb and 'the happy few' who supported their leadership over the past four years, gifted Woodstock its best Town Council in two decades.
They reformed the finances, the admin structure and attempted (ultimately unsuccessfully) to introduce into Council business high standards of decency and appropriate behaviour. They brought WiFi, recorders and a mike system to the Town Hall, along with new accounts software. They supported the 'no' to Botley West, the smart parking scheme and set up direct access to the WTC website for our thriving local societies to create an online local events diary which is highly valued by them. In an attempt to heal the time-wasting bitter feuds of the past, Nick's first act was to nominate, as his deputy, someone from the opposing side.
As council tax payers await a 'new' Council which includes, unfortunately, many of those who did so much to obstruct the serious work of the outgoing Councillors, and some of whom have spent what seems like a lifetime in office, now is the time to respect on what still needs to be done.
Major unresolved internal issues remain. We need to be told why four Town Clerks have left the employment of WTC in about as many years, some with expensive non-disclosure or other leaving agreements. It is said this is because one or two Councillors behaved towards them in an impossible manner but we do not know, even though we should. Why is one Councillor even suing his own Council? Why should Woodstock residents not be allowed to know what has gone on behind closed doors, especially as it is our money that has been spent. There should be no place for NDAs nor secret deals in public life.
Turning to the world outside the Town Hall, WTC has two major inter-connected issues to address. First, the so-called Solar Farm which are being pushed remorselessly (and shamelessly) by Blenheim. Russian cash and Chinese plastic should not be allowed to destroy the fine historic farmlands and fields that grace our north Oxfordshire environment.
And secondly, Blenheim is now seemingly intent on turning Woodstock into its client cash-cow (and cats-paw), whether to build new homes (Blenheim won't allow solar panels to be fitted on them, they presumably want to sell purchasers their own Blenheim electricity), or by encroaching on the life of the Town by use of the Town Gate and clogging up the A44 with very noisy 'Disney' events. Nor should we forget that the two last WTC's took their eye off the ball in failing to demand Section 106 funding from developers to compensate local residents for years of serious disturbance and damage to roads, including the five year new and rebuilding project that is Woodstock House.
These matters need a functioning Council machine. Will we get one? The Mayor and his team steadfastly attended 95% of Council meetings. Yet some of the most obstructive and cash-wasting Councillors will remain on the Council, and some of them have the appalling attendance records. One persistent 'point of order' enthusiast attended only 55% of meetings, a supporter of his just one for the whole of the last year! As a former Councillor myself, I am only too aware of the hard graft required.
Anthony Glees
Letter - Nick Stewart - May 2024
Dear Editor,
Being a regular reader of The Week, the following caught my eye in 13 April issue: 'A town council in Norfolk has introduced a system that allows councillors to raise a card if they want to leave a meeting because they're in distress. The system was set up after a Tory councillor accused fellow members of 'achieving nothing', causing a Green councillor to experience a brief 'psychiatric emergency'. Councillors who raise a card can take time out in a room where they can be advised on 'grounding techniques.' Given the reported behaviour of some of our Woodstock Town councillors perhaps it is high time to introduce a similar card system? Or, alternatively, the yellow/red card system used in football matches!
Nick Stewart
Letter - Linda Glees - June 2024
Dear Editor,
In your May edition it was stated in an obituary that the funds for the refurbishment of the Woodstock Community Centre were raised by the celebrations for 'Woodstock at 900’.
In fact, I'm afraid that this is inaccurate, and as WOBL is a local paper of record (deposited as such in the archives of the Bodleian Library) it is important to set the record straight.
The funds needed for the long overdue refurbishment were the result of serious fund-raising work undertaken by Victoria Edwards, Deputy Mayor at the time, and myself. Woodstock Town Council contributed a sum of £60,000 which had been raised by the sale of a council property. We then applied widely for grants and sought private donations. West Oxfordshire District Council allocated a grant of £35,000 and the balance came from generous residents and charitable trusts. It would be a shame if this successful community effort were to be misremembered and mis-recorded.
Yours sincerely,
Linda Glees
Letter - Nick Manby-Brown - June 2024
I would like to comment on Stan Scott's letter in May's issue. I was very happy and proud to become the Town Mayor, and I enjoyed my time in office. The chairing of meetings was just one of the Mayor's roles, and I took 21 out of 22 meetings. I tried to chair as fairly as I could, and I concentrated on getting the Council business done first.
During my year, not one person queried the way I conducted meetings to my face. The Council has a chequered and difficult history of meetings, as can be seen by past Minutes, and I feel my term was a good year for the Council. The new way of filming and recording meetings helped with both conduct and transparency. I wish the New Council every success.
Nick Manby-Brown
Letter - Alison Foster - June 2024
Dear Editor,
I just want to mention what a lovely time we had visiting Bridewell Gardens on their recent Open Day in May! I read about it in your magazine (in the March issue) and decided to go along.
It was surprisingly located in Wilcote (a nearby village we had not heard of), and we approached it by driving through Finstock. You wouldn't know it was there unless you went looking for it! We were ushered into a parking space in the adjacent field and were warmly greeted at their makeshift ‘reception tent’ with offerings of their own packets of flower seeds and information about what we’d find there. It was a wonderfully sunny Sunday and we saw England at its very best! So, I do encourage others to go as they do wonderful work there helping people to recover from bouts of severe depression and mental illness - giving them much needed companionship, gentle and rewarding tasks, interesting knowledge and experience that lasts a lifetime, and a lot of hope for their future We looked around the potting sheds and greenhouses; strolled along 'the avenue', through the topiaries and the kitchen garden enjoying the herbs and flowers; then strolled past the olive trees on the other side of the walled garden to admire their vineyards beyond and to learn about their different compost heaps. We then sat down for a cup of tea and home-made cake in their pop-up café complete with bunting, enjoying the gentle hum of civilised chat and conversation.
They still have Open days you can go to: on Sundays 9 June; 14 July and 15 September, so do go and visit this special place while you can!
Alison Foster
Letter - Kevin Markey - Sept 2024
Dear Sirs Mrs Lesley Seligman: can anyone help? I am seeking memories of Lesley Seligman, a former resident of Woodstock House.
Lesley was the wife of Henry Seligman, a German Jew who was interned on the Isle of Man and later was involved with atomic research. Lesley also had a brother Michael Gordon Bradley (1923--1998).
My link is tenuous! Their daughter Gisela lived with my great grand parents, one of three to live with relatives of mine and the final one to complete my research.
I am hoping to get more information to lead me to Gisela and/or her brothers who I now know were called Andrew and Paul.They were both born in Oxford and one or both may still be alive.
I am happy for my email to be given out: kevmarkey08@aol.com
Kevin Markey
Letter - Stan Scott - Sept 2024
Dear Editor
Can there be any doubt that our doctors are the most hard working, respected and valuable people in Woodstock and the whole area? Odd then that the future of our health care is on their shoulders, with not much help so far from the NHS, Blenheim as developers or the County and District councils? Blenheim have apparently offered to build something on the Banbury Road site, well out of town and no buses.
Nothing is guaranteed and might not happen for many years, if at all. The old police station, which they also own, stands empty, and is large, central, close to the shops, near the buses and has lots of parking. Even on a temporary rented basis it would be ideal for doctors and patients.
Doctors have said they will listen to patients, and our town council is considering ways in which we can all be consulted.
Stan Scott
Letter - Jo Lamb - Sept 2024
Dear Editor, The word 'Democracy', according to my Collins Thesaurus, is taken from the Greek word 'demos', meaning people and 'kratos', meaning strength. In current political terms a democracy is a system of self government by the people; or at least, it should be. Again, according to my thesaurus, a democratic system of government is one which is self governing, egalitarian and representative of the populist view.
So how does this apply to our system of local government and in particular to the recent operations of Woodstock Town Council (WTC), granted that our current Councillors did not even have to submit to an electoral Parish Council vote last May because alas, there were insufficient Town Council candidates prepared to stand? It seems to me that an invaluable tool available to current Councillors is actually to listen to and to hear what the local electorate might wish to communicate to them; common sense and common courtesy surely? It is for this reason that each WTC agenda provides for a 'public participation' section at the beginning of each meeting. It is a massive aid to communication between the electorate and the Council.
Whilst it is acknowledged that the Council's current Standing Orders provide that matters raised in public participation can only be those relating to items on the Agenda for that specific meeting nevertheless, the Agenda content itself is ultimately controlled by the Mayor and/or Deputy Mayor alone (in conjunction with the Town Clerk). Arguably therefore, the Agenda itself might not necessarily reflect all the concerns of the local electorate or indeed sometimes, all the concerns of individual Councillors.
In recognition of this apparent constraint on the principles of democracy, WTC's website provides unambiguously within its rules on Public Participation that: "The Town Council has changed its standing orders on the rights of residents to address the Council. Now, the public can speak on any topic relevant to the affairs of the Council whether or not it is on the agenda. The Council hopes that this will encourage people to air their views on matters of local interest" This much is clear. So far so good! Participation by the public at Council meetings upon matters of concern to them, is an essential component of democracy and communication between the electors and our Councillors.
What a shocking surprise that it was then, to those of us who attended the WTC meeting on Tuesday 10th September, when the Mayor (who was audibly and insistently prompted by the Deputy Mayor in this respect), announced that only topics related directly to items on the agenda for that meeting, could be raised in public participation by the members of the public. As I was told subsequently, one of the items which would have been raised by one public speaker was to have been the state and condition of some of the town's bus shelters. The opportunity to raise this directly through public participation was vetoed purely because the topic of bus shelters was not on the agenda for that day. As a result of this unilateral and narrow interpretation of Standing Orders, there was absolutely no public speaking at the WTC meeting on 10th September. Many of those present concluded that this was an appalling turn of events.
How undemocratic was this outcome? Highly, I would suggest. Is the proverbial 'tail' (ie certain Councillors) now trying to 'wag the dog' (ie, the populace)? Is there an intention emerging from within the Council which is to restrict the content of free speech by the electorate? It would seem so. It is a great shame that neither of the (only) three other Councillors present at this meeting raised any objection to the evident erosion of democratic representation in this instance. There was a deafening silence in the Mayor's Parlour at this moment ! This was not a good day for the electorate in Woodstock. It was a dreadful day for democracy within this town, which many will hope will never occur again. Come on Town Council! Kindly correct your interpretation of what should be democracy enabling rules….. "kratos" to the "demos" one could say?! Councillors might begin by sorting out the current Standing Orders which could be aligned say, to those of West Oxfordshire District Council which allow for proper participation in Council meetings. After all, we are meant to be living in a democracy and this is the twenty-first century.
Yours,
Jo Lamb
Letter - Michael Farley - Sept 2024
Sir, Residents' Parking: In the first year of residential parking in Woodstock the County Council raised just over £250k.
Interestingly 62% of the income came from pay and display. I make no comment on the rights or wrongs of this policy, readers can come to their own conclusions from the breakdown of income in the table below:
June 2023 to July 2024 Residents permits £28,535 Visitor permits £925 Hotel permits £27,000 Business permits £4,920 Pay and Display income £155,119 Penalty Charge Notice £33,710 Currently residents' permits at £65.00 are the lowest in Oxfordshire, they rise to £110 in many other towns/areas.
What chance OCC exploit this cash cow in our town in the years to come?
Michael Farley
Letter - Christopher Donald - Sept 2024
Dear Sir
Some of your readers will already know that on 12th August there was a court case in Oxford which was brought by Mr Sharone Parnes against Woodstock Town Council (case ref. 355MC672). It was a public hearing before Judge Lumb, several of our community being present. Mr Parnes has been a councillor on Woodstock Town Council for over ten years.
Councillor Parnes’ case involving personal damages against the Town Council was struck out by the judge for a whole series of reasons and accordingly costs of £1168.50 were awarded against Councillor Parnes This is a most unusual case both as to parties, claim, possible conflict of interest, judgement and award of costs against plaintiff as well as the long duration of proceedings. Now that the case has been struck out the electors of Woodstock must feel entitled to some public disclosures.
The Judges strictures speak for themselves but such disclosures are the least the electors should expect. Specifically the Mayor should require Councillor Parnes to account for his conduct which can be seen as most unbecoming of a councillor. In the context of an elected councillor it would be entirely reasonable to expect a public personal statement in the absence of which electors will like me be left with an uncomfortable feeling undermining respect for and confidence in Woodstock Town Council.
Yours faithfully,
Christopher Donald
Letter - Anthony Glees - Oct 2024
Dear Editor
The September edition of your excellent news magazine has much of great interest to everyone in Woodstock. To those of us with a particular concern for the future of our lovely Town, two major long-term issues in particular jump out of your pages.
The first comes from the report of the Probus Club. We learn that “Further capital investment has been going into ‘London-Oxford Airport’ to support expansion. [There is] a new three hanger facility built for the helicopter part of Airbus at a cost of £50m…Flight control has also benefitted with a new upgrade in the Radar system. This means they are able to land a greater variety of aircraft including small [sic] commercial aircraft, the sort that you see at London City Airport”.
“All this has led to the Airspace-Public Consultation which is currently underway. In the next phase of the Consultation, the proposed take-off and landing utilisation of airspace and flightpaths will be put forward. This should include both fixed wing and rotary aircraft and is the phase Woodstock and surrounding villages need to consider very carefully in providing comment”.
How many of us were aware we had been ‘consulted’? We must wonder how we can ensure we are properly protected for aircraft noise pollution (which is already clearly on the increase) and the dangerous dumping of fuel in our area. We are already suffering from increased helicopter and fixed wing flights over Woodstock, some (allegedly) taking so-called A Listers to Estelle Manor and the Soho Farmhouse.
Secondly, we read, yet again that the Blenheim managers continue to relentlessly press forward not simply with the so-called Solar Farm project but also with changes to the use of the Estate, with ever more weekend events which impact directly on the life of Woodstock. There is also an ongoing traffic issue which must be addressed. On Saturday 31 August, for example, when as far as one could tell there was nothing special going on, the tail-back of traffic on the A44 at 1100 reached as far as Yarnton. Everyone was inconvenienced by this including those on the buses.
London-Oxford Airport (what a silly name, to be honest, 'Kidlington' would be just fine and rather more accurate) and Blenheim should feel that it is being very carefully monitored by the representatives of Woodstock’s citizenry and be made to understand that it cannot ride roughshod over us with impunity.
To this end, I have written to the new Mayor of Woodstock and Councillors to ask for that a single Councillor be designated to keep an eagle eye on both these issues, as was the case in the past and report fully to all of us. This would, in my opinion, be a vital step to ensuring that this generation passes on the unique heritage of Woodstock and to future generations.
Yours,
Anthony Glees
Letter - Bob Pomfret - Oct 2024
Dear Editor
I seem to spend a lot of time thinking about the proposal for the Botley West solar farm and I’d appreciate it if you would allow me to share my thoughts in the Woodstock and Bladon News.
I’ve been walking, running and enjoying the wildlife on the fields around Woodstock for more than sixty years and if I’m entirely honest I’d really rather they were not covered with solar panels. Trouble is, I also know that the climate is changing and the world is becoming a more difficult place for many people, not to mention other species, to live in.
I’m also not proud of the legacy that me and my generation are leaving for those that follow us and, although I hate putting my head up over the parapet on a controversial subject, I’d like to explain why I feel we should engage with and probably support the Botley West project.
- Solar is clean sustainable energy. It is quiet energy, it does not smell and does not have polluting waste products
Nobody is drilling or digging up anything and it won’t run out as long as we need it.
- It’s local energy, made in the UK and not affected by international politics and incidents.
- It can be a short term solution. If something better comes along in the next few years, the infrastructure is relatively easy to decommission and the land returned to agricultural use.
I’m not pretending to be an expert, but I’ve read a lot of angry headline grabbing stuff from people against the project and my gut feeling is that they are wrong; that fundamentally large scale solar is a sensible way forward to supply us with the electricity we need and edge us towards a net zero future.
I hate it when people say 'what's the point?. This project is just a drop in the ocean and won’t make a significant difference'. I don’t believe in giving up. I’d like to think that I am an optimist about the future and part of the reason is that schemes like this are starting to be built.
My last thought is a question I ask myself. If this project were 20 miles away would I think it was a good idea? And, the truth is, I would. And, for me, that kind of seals it. Even though it actually hurts me to think that the landscape around me, my landscape, would be changed for the rest of my life. I refuse to be a ‘not in my backyard’ person. We owe it to our children and grandchildren and the generations to follow
Thank you, with Regards,
Bob Pomfret
Letter - Jo Lamb - Oct 2024
Dear Editor,
The urgent need for a new surgery for Woodstock has been an ongoing subject for local discussion for years. The subject is not rocket science but it is made more complicated by the numbers of participants involved in the discussions and the often conflicting commercial interests of the parties involved.
It would be wrong to think that our local government leaders (eg, the County, District or Town Councils) are directly involved in the provision of a new surgery. They are not prime movers in this instance. Our local representatives are at best merely facilitators, trying to get the parties around the negotiating table.
Personally, I don’t think our local Town Council is of much significance in this issue at all. The main players are the GPs themselves, (some of whom own the current inadequate site and are likely to want to access their capital investment for their personal need), the NHS (which stipulates what is required for the site and the building but doesn’t have funding available to pay to build it) and the Blenheim Estates Trust (which own the land and whose S106 statutory capital obligations are dependent upon more house building). The Government pays the GPs for some of their business activities but they seem to stand back from taking responsibility for injecting capital into a new surgery building.
Slightly more on the fringe of these discussions, I would suggest, is the Bus Company because if it transpires that the surgery has to be built outside the immediate town centre, the new building must be made regularly and easily accessible by local transport for people who are likely to be pretty unwell. Without easy access to it, the new building would merely be a “white elephant”.
So please can we lock representatives from each of these prime movers into a room and throw away the key, until a viable and sensible agreement as to the new surgery building is reached by them? Only then should these individuals be let out of detention! The discussion around this critical need for Woodstock has gone on long enough. The losers are local patients who are losing patience.
Pardon the pun! Yours,
Jo Lamb
Letter - Hilary Brown - Oct 2024
Dear Editor,
I was hoping to inform readers that our council agreed to take action on bus shelters … a positive story. Not to be, sadly. Despite being contrary to practice, the council announced without warning that the public could not speak, unless it was a subject on their agenda. They read Standing Order 3e but offered no further explanation. However, they did, omit to read the additional text ‘to encourage people to air their views on matters of local interest, now the public can speak on any topic relevant to the affairs of the Council whether or not it is on the agenda’. A few made an attempt to question the sudden change of practice but the response was uncompromising, disappointing and frankly unfriendly… their response … an emphatic “NO”. Consequently – no public participated, even though before the meeting, at least 3 residents planned to speak. Although thwarted, I did write to the Town Clerk asking if he would submit the subject of repairing the shelters to the councillors and asked him to confirm the procedure for us to follow.
We really would like ‘a little help from our friends’ … in the council.
Hilary Brown
Letter - Anthony Glees - Nov 2024
Dear Editor
Last month you were kind enough to publish a letter from me, asking that Woodstock Town Council (WTC) appoint a councillor to monitor the expansion of two major enterprises, Blenheim and ‘London-Kidlington’ Airport. I mentioned that I put this proposal to WTC directly on 2 September.
Whilst I have had no official answer from WTC, off the record I’m told WTC has now appointed two councillors to address these key issues, and that Cllr the Duke of Marlborough will monitor Blenheim and Cllr Parnes the Airport. The former is a prized, if rare, attendee at WTC and the latter recently failed in his attempt to sue WTC for thousands of pounds of damages.
Whether WTC considered any possible conflicts of interest in making these two appointments (the clue to the former is in the name, and to the latter his failed court action) we do not, of course know and recent rule changes to the making of public representations to WTC meetings mean we may never to know.
Please forgive me for writing to you again this month but about another issue altogether, the latest so-called ‘WTC Parking Survey’.
Anyone with even a nodding acquaintance of how to conduct a survey scientifically will raise an eyebrow at the scrap of paper recently posted through our letter-boxes, containing 14 questions. Respondents are not asked for their names or addresses and that the ‘survey’ can be completed online as well as on paper - so there’s no way, it seems, of preventing multiple responses by using both paper and online to give them (twice over for couples) As you peruse the questions on the ‘survey’, you can only smile. They are aimed at those who ‘have a connection with the Town’, and Q. 10 is addressed specifically to those who ‘live outside’ it, without defining what this means (in the Shire? In England? Overseas?) - or what the locus standi of such folk should be in evaluating their responses But it gets worse. Every single question asking respondents for an opinion on the Scheme leads with a hostile or negative prompt. To the first question, about shopping in Woodstock, the ‘survey’ asks if the Scheme has ‘strongly discouraged’ respondents from shopping in Woodstock, or ‘somewhat discouraged’ them. Ditto the question of how the Scheme has impacted on their businesses (the prompt is for ‘strongly discouraged’). Question 8 requires a ‘yes’ or ‘no’ answer to whether the Scheme has stopped us attending functions in Town Hall or Community centre (not whether it has facilitated attendance). The ‘survey’ concludes with a hotchpotch of questions including whether respondents would like to ‘increase the fee parking period’ (surely they mean ‘free’) and whether the scheme ‘should be removed altogether’ (we imagine they hoped for answer is ‘yes’).
Who devised the ‘survey’? How will we get to learn the total number of respondents? Not revealing the number of respondents is a well-tried way of foxing the public.
Candidly, it does seem that the aim of this ‘survey’ is to attempt, yet again, to re-open and discredit the parking Scheme, despite the District Council election where the pro-Scheme candidate won 51% of the vote and the antiScheme person just 28% and the fact that the Scheme works so well.
Councillors' wily strategies are often good for a laugh. But bearing in mind that it is our money that is being wasted on this ‘survey’ and that so many serious problems in our Town are not being addressed, it seems fair to wonder if it is not WTC who is having the last laugh - on us, at our expense. Literally.
Anthony Glees
Letter - Sue McGlynn - Nov 2024
Dear Editor
I returned to Woodstock after a short period away and was horrified to see the condition of the once beautiful, mature trees within the Woodstock Conservation Area. Their value to the town centre environment is incalculable - now nearly every tree has been severely pollarded, leaving just a stump.
Trees are an essential element of the street scene and experience of the Conservation Area. They provide multiple benefits beyond the visual and aesthetic. There are probably many more but these are just a few of the benefits:
- Modify climate in urban settings
- Help to clean the air
- Provide habitat for birds and insects
- Increase well being by bringing greenery into built up areas
- Reduce vehicle speeds in the carriageway through 'side friction'
- Soften the visual impact of car parking in streets.
Clearly, trees need to be managed carefully to remain healthy and safe. It is evident that the trees have been pollarded previously and that this was a standard practice in tree surgery. However, there must be less brutal methods of managing trees within such a significant streetscape, such as more limited thinning and lopping or pollarding more gradually over a period of time so that the impact is lessened.
A representative of Oxfordshire County Council Countryside and Tree Service has agreed to meet me to explain their approach to tree maintenance and I hope this may prompt a review of methods for the care of street trees in the future.
For now, the damage is done and for a considerable time the centre of Woodstock will be a degraded experience for all - residents, tourists, business owners and visitors alike. There will be no trees marking the seasons, no bird song, nowhere to hang the Christmas lights and nothing but tree stumps and overflowing bins in the streets Who, if anyone, is actively protecting and conserving our beautiful town?
Susan McGlynn
Please see pictures of the pollarded trees on the inside back cover
Letter - Giles Lewis - Nov 2024
Dear Editor,
Bob Pomfret is right when he refers in his ###Letter (WOBL, October ed.) to the Botley West project being controversial.
Just one of the reasons for this is that large scale solar is very inefficient when compared to other sources of renewable energy. As little as 11% efficient, it is approximately half as efficient as onshore – and one quarter as efficient as offshore – wind. The UK is very nearly the least suitable country for solar power in all of Europe due to those characteristics of its weather that have been only too obvious this summer. Its delivery of energy can only be termed clean if the highly carbon-intensive process of manufacturing its panels and shipping them from China is conveniently ignored; as also the use of elemental and metal materials that are dug up, using fossil-fuelled mining plant to do so.
As with electric cars, China will inevitably tighten its current grip on the source of these materials, thereby undoubtedly leading to 'international politics and incidents'.
Eleven-mile long Botley West will be the biggest solar development in Europe if it goes ahead. The infrastructure required for two million solar panels on this huge 3,200-acre project includes concrete posts and blockhouses – one in every field-sized area – plus the cabling, 110 km of fencing and security lighting required. Rapid obsolescence in solar panel technology will shorten its life to much less than the putative 40 years. It is debateable as to who will pick up a half billion-pound tab for decommissioning the development. More likely this mainly Green Belt land - much of it BMV farmland As for our legacy left to future generations, our concern should lie with the current 'net zero or bust' policy pursued by our government. It will impoverish our country, render us uncompetitive and insecure in a geo-politically dangerous world, and leave a landscape degraded by rusting panels on our once-cherished countryside.
Giles Lewis
Letter - Arron Bowman-Smith - Nov 2024
Dear Editor,
Having missed out on the opportunity to add my signature to the 28 residents who wrote to the Town Council before Wednesday's meeting, I am writing to express my deep dissatisfaction with the recent actions taken by Woodstock Town Council, actions that I and many other residents see as a gross display of disregard for transparent governance and respect for the community.
The resignation of Mayor John Banbury, after a brief five months, left residents in the dark and raised many questions.
Instead of responding openly, the Council hastily convened a meeting, at which only six councillors were present. To choose Ann Grant as Mayor under such dubious circumstances, without even a clear explanation for the urgency or need, is an affront to fair governance. To proceed with such a significant decision, particularly in a way that undermines public input and bypasses established protocols, is nothing short of a bold overreach.
Additionally, recent changes to public participation procedures making it nearly impossible for residents to address the Council without prior councillor approval are nothing less than an attempt to silence the very voices the Council is elected to serve. This shift flies in the face of the Local Government Transparency Code (2014), a clear violation of the public’s right to contribute to local decision-making.
Further concerns include the questionable handling of grant allocations, with critical meetings rescheduled at the last minute, causing some Councillors to miss them entirely. The lack of transparency in these decisions, coupled with potential conflicts of interest, seriously undermines trust in the Council’s motives.
The Town Clerk’s recent conflicting statements around procedural changes have only added to the confusion Woodstock residents deserve a clear, honest explanation, not contradictory statements and haphazard decisionmaking. Additionally, the ongoing issue with Councillor Parnes’ legal dispute with WTC has cast a long shadow over the Council’s integrity, a situation that demands thorough public disclosure and accountability The WTC exists to serve the interests of Woodstock’s residents, not to advance individual agendas or circumvent established democratic processes. The recent conduct has been a stark reminder that this Council seems to have lost sight of its purpose, forgetting the duty it has to the public.
In light of these issues, I urge the WTC to restore trust by holding an Extraordinary Town Meeting, allowing Councillors to address the community directly, answer the questions and account for recent actions. Our town deserves leadership that upholds transparency, respect for procedure, and accountability to the public. This standard must be met, anything less is a disservice to us all.
Mr Bowman-Smith
Letter - Andrew Hennell - Dec 2024
Section S106 Oxfordshire County Council being the local authority for Oxfordshire is supposedly committed to delivering top quality services and value for money on behalf of the county's 600,000+ residents. However, having run a business in Woodstock since 1996 as well as living in town, I have witnessed a deterioration in the service levels that are available to Woodstock residents.
New housing has dramatically increased the town’s population without any thought or mitigation given to how already overstretched essential services such as school places and GP appointment availability at the Woodstock Surgery are increased. The pavements are cracked with loose paving which is hazardous especially for elderly people, there is an abundance of litter strewn around town, weeds are allowed to grow unchecked with deep roots establishing themselves at the base of stone walls which will eventually cause structural damage to properties many of which are Listed buildings, just to name a few areas of concern.
A lack of funding seems to be the common excuse and reason given for service levels having deteriorated, so imagine my surprise to learn that ‘cash-strapped’ Oxfordshire County Council had £278 million stashed away in its bank accounts in May 2024 which had been received as compulsory payments by housing developers under rules contained within Section 106 of the Town & Country Planning Act 1990.
These compulsory payments are made by housing developers to Oxfordshire County Council which must be used to mitigate any negative effect that new houses being built will have on the essential services such as schools, pavements, footpaths Etc. Sensible one would have thought, as an increase of residents living in an area will of course put pressure on already over-stretched essential services and the infrastructure in general.
It appears as if Oxfordshire County Council had however ‘banked’ the £278 million of money paid across to them by the aforementioned housing developers under Section 106 and they have not used that money for the purposes that it was intended. To make matters worse, there’s the possibility that housing developers might seek to claw back the unspent money after five years of it not having been used.
Looking at the situation further, it appears as if Oxfordshire County Council had collected, received and ‘banked’ £16.1 million by May 2024 from Section 106 payments which should have been used to improve services in Woodstock and Chipping Norton combined.
The £278 million and the Woodstock/Chipping Norton £16.1 million is not the definitive figure and the end of this ‘banked’ money scandal, because each time a housing developer receives planning permission to build new houses in our area, they are obligated to pay additional monies across to Oxfordshire County Council under Section 106, so the aforementioned ‘banked’ figures will surely rise as time passes.
All towns must be fit for purpose and be able to support the needs of residents. There are a number of services in Woodstock which fall outside of an acceptable standard that need to be addressed May I suggest that Woodstock Town Council challenges Oxfordshire County Council and insists that the Section 106 money that should have been used to benefit Woodstock and improve services that has been ‘banked’, is immediately released and used for the purpose that it was intended which in turn will benefit all Woodstock residents.
Andrew Hennell, Antiques Of Woodstock
Letter - Colin Baldwin - Dec 2024
Pollarded Trees and Christmas Lights I write to support the views of the ###Letter in your last issue from Susan McGlynn. I don't live in any of the streets in which the trees have been pollarded, so I can't comment on the birdsong etc but I do think that Woodstock looks a worse place for the work done.
I moved to Woodstock twelve or so years ago and when I got a chance to have a clear look at the place I thought how lucky we are to live in such a beautiful town. My friends that visit from Oxford and further afield also comment with the same view.
I am no arboriculturist but I do know that one can pollard trees any time within their dormancy period, which can be as late as May in some years but can be safely treated up to the end of March in all years So why do so shortly after the Christmas lights are placed on them? The lights in Woodstock are always something to look forward to. I realise there are still some lights on the smaller trees but the larger trees when lit are so much more impressive during the festive period. I was pleased to see the lights going up earlier this year only to find a week or so later they weren't there and the trees had been butchered.
I assume that there is a chargeable cost to the work of erection of the lighting, when I asked who was responsible I was told there are two councils involved. The Town Council and Oxfordshire County Council. When I asked who on earth was responsible for the extra cost, I was told that it was us, apparently. It is clear to me that neither of the two councils consult with one another.
I assume that when asked each council would blame the other. Is this due to petty rivalry or just total incompetence? I do notice from the WOBL that there seems to be a lot of unrest within the Town Council. A lot of questions were asked in the last issue and perhaps when this issue comes out we may have some clearer answers given. It does look, reading the last WOBL, as though someone needs to grab the subject by the scruff of the neck and sort the trouble out.
C.W.Baldwin
Letter - Graham Brown - Dec 2024
Solar Power
I wrote to this magazine just over a year ago about solar power, trying to balance some issues arising from the Botley West project and would like to do this again.
It is widely accepted now that there is a critical need to generate clean energy to reduce carbon emissions to fight climate change. To this end, solar and wind are relatively quick, easy and cheap ways to do this. Yes, they are not perfect but they are currently the best tools we have. The comprehensive report from the World Bank from 2020 (Solar Power Potential by Country) states that the UK is second from bottom on the ranking of the potential of countries to generate solar power but it also states that even here in the UK it is a worthwhile exercise. That is the reason we see solar farms and solar panels all around us. Oxfordshire needs energy and our area is considered unsuitable for onshore wind which therefore leaves solar. The under investment in the National Grid means there are only certain areas where large scale solar can be installed and connected, Botley West has that connection. The Government is desperately trying to catch up on a lack of action in the last 20 years and solar is a relatively fast way to do this. Studies show that solar installations, depending on their location, become carbon neutral after 2-6 years. The website of the Low Carbon Hub, a social enterprise based in Oxford which develops community-owned renewable energy installations, has an excellent Q & A section on Botley West which debunks myths and misinformation about solar power. We need to install solar on roofs and in fields, as quickly as possible, this is an emergency.
So what can we do? Wait, leave it to others, hope for the best? Engaging in the process will help. Push for more and push hard. Push for more tree planting, better hedges, more wildlife reserves, more public footpaths, more biodiversity, more community benefit. If this project does go ahead then the community benefit fund of £50K a year offered by the developers to the local communities is insulting for a project of this size. A similar project in Nottingham is offering £1million a year, other renewable projects far more…
Graham Brown
Letter - Arron Bowman-Smith - Dec 2024
Woodstock Town Council (WTC)
I am writing in to raise serious concerns a bout what appears to be gross failings in governance and transparency at Woodstock Town Council (WTC). These alleged failures have left many in the community disillusioned and questioning whether this council is fit to serve.
As a result, I have formally requested that West Oxfordshire District Council investigate WTC’s conduct and consider disbanding the current council, paving the way for fresh elections. While this is a drastic step, I believe it is necessary given the weight of the allegations and the damage already done to public confidence.
The following key issues warrant immediate attention:
- Leadership Failures*Mayor John Banbury’s abrupt resignation has yet to be fully explained, leaving the community in the dark. What followed was a hastily arranged meeting where Cllr Ann Grant was appointed as the new Mayor, with what appears to be little to no transparency or public engagement in the process.
- Suppression of Public Voices*The recently implemented Public Participation Protocol has, in effect, stripped residents of meaningful opportunities to engage with their elected representatives. It grants the Chair unchecked power to silence speakers and even allows for the use of police to remove individuals - policies that appear to contravene Article 10 of the Human Rights Act 1998 and stifle democratic freedoms.
- Censorship Through Policies*The Notice Board and Entrance Halls Policy actively bans materials critical of the council, suppressing dissenting voices and undermining accountability. This attempt to control criticism and stifle public discourse is alarming and raises serious questions about the council’s commitment to openness and transparency.
- Mismanagement and Confusion*Poorly scheduled meetings and conflicting procedural statements have created unnecessary confusion among both Councillors and residents. Meanwhile, ongoing legal disputes involving a sitting Councillor cast a further shadow over the council’s integrity, leaving the community in doubt about its ability to manage itself effectively.
The people of Woodstock deserve a council that upholds democratic principles, values public participation, and operates with integrity. Instead, the current WTC has allegedly demonstrated incompetence, disregard for transparency, and an apparent lack of accountability to its constituents.
By calling for a thorough investigation and the potential disbandment of the Council, I aim to restore trust in our local governance and ensure that Woodstock is represented by leaders who respect and prioritise their community I strongly encourage the residents of Woodstock to stand together, demand better from their elected representatives, and push for leadership that values transparency, accountability, and the rights of its constituents. To those sitting on the current Council, I urge you to reflect on your actions and remember your responsibility is to serve the public, not silence them.
Thank you for your attention to this matter.
Mr Bowman-Smith
Editor Comment: The retiring Mayor and the three resigning Councillors were contacted to ask whether they wanted to submit a letter.