Woodstock & Bladonnews

Letters to the Editor

Letters to the Editor - 2025

From Letters to the Editor 2022 to Dec 2025 · Online 31 December 2025

Letter - Nick Stewart - Jan 2025

Dear Editor,

I like Christmas

In fact, it’s one of my favourite times of the year. However, I was shocked to read the Woodstock Town Council (WTC) minutes of the 12 November meeting when “the Clerk reported that to enhance Woodstock’s Christmas lights, five fully decorated 7 foot Christmas trees will be delivered, at a cost of around £4,500”.

WTC has bags of money but to spend this amount of money on five Christmas trees is outrageous and a waste of public money. Judging by the number of comments on 'We Love Woodstock', there are many other people who share my point of view.

It would be fascinating to know more about the buying decision process carried out by WTC including how many quotes were obtained (three is standard practice), testimonials from satisfied customers and whether the chosen supplier is local and environmentally friendly.

At the same meeting on 12 November, another decision was made by WTC that also shocked me. This time it wasn’t about how much money was spent for so little, but how little WTC donated to a charitable cause. A request from the North Oxfordshire Food Bank for support for Christmas parcels for Woodstock had been received. The total cost would be £250 and the Council proposal was to provide £115. After discussion it was decided that £100 would be donated. I find it hard to believe that a discussion was even needed; surely £250 should have been proposed and seconded without further ado – perhaps double the original request. It’s good to know that the Christmas spirit is alive and well amongst the current WTC councillors! Yet again at the 12 November meeting, the subject of the much needed repair and replacement of the town’s bus shelters was discussed. It was acknowledged that waiting for S106 money from the development of Hill Rise would take many years. The possibility of asking Blenheim to contribute to the Hensington shelter was also discussed. As I mentioned above, WTC has bags of money so why is it even considering asking Blenheim for a contribution or mentioning S106 money? In my view, it could easily afford to pay for the bus shelters out of its own money.

And when I say bags of money, as at 31 March 2014 WTC had £363,000 in its bank account. By 31 October 2014, this amount had risen to £464,000! So, in just seven months, an increase of £122,000 or over £17,000 per month. I appreciate that WTC needs to keep something in reserve, but it needs to get its priorities right and start spending for the good of the Woodstock community.

Nick Stewart


Letter - Giles Lewis - Jan 2025

Botley West It's the final straight for the Botley West Solar Farm

On Friday last, 13 December, the Planning Inspectorate formally accepted their Application for an 'array and connection structure' from Photovolt Development Partners (PVDP) on behalf of SolarFive Ltd. In doing so, the Inspectorate thereby declined to uphold claims, including one in admirable detail from Stop Botley West, that PVDP`s public consultation was faulty.

The Pre-examination stage for this Nationally Significant Infrastructure Project has therefore begun during which you will be able to have your (further) say. You will, though, need to register as an interested party within 28 days after the invitation to do so appears on the Inspectorate`s website. With your registration, you will need to include your summary comments on what main issues and impacts of the project you wish to challenge Once the registration period closes the examination proper begins. If you have registered, you will then be able to submit more information in support of your summary comments.

The full Examination period can last no longer than six months and is therefore likely to close by the end of August this year. The Inspectorate`s recommendations then go direct to Secretary of State, Ed Milliband, for a final decision.

For further information and updates go to the Planning Inspectorate website; then click on 'Find a National Infrastructure Project'; click on English Projects; then search for 'Botley West'.

The Application consists of about 250 documents and thousands of pages of sometimes technical detail. A comprehensible way into it, and into writing your summary as an interested party, is to read – and in my opinion to challenge – PVDP's arguments in support of their Application as seen in their Planning Supporting Statement. Follow this link to it in the 'Other Documents' section of the Application: https://search.app/ozynMu6FWLsRCXQv6 Stop Botley West will also be setting a lead on issues arising from the Inspectorate's examination of this project on https://stopbotleywest.com

Giles Lewis


Letter - Sophy Clough - Jan 2025

Christmas Lights

It was hugely disappointing to return from New Zealand in December, anticipating all the beauty and style of the Christmas season in Woodstock, to find the trees had been butchered – there is no other word for it – and our lovely Christmas lights had been replaced by gaudy trees in pots. The RHS suggests late winter/early spring as the best time to pollard trees, and advises not to pollard in autumn as this increases the risk of decay fungi entering pruning cuts. If this brutal approach to Woodstock’s trees must be taken in preference to regular, more subtle tree maintenance, surely it could wait until after Christmas.

Sophy Clough


Letter - Ed King - FebMar 2025

The Black Prince I pass the now closed Black Prince pub every day and and every day it looks more neglected and run down. It would be wonderful if WOBL could contact the owner and ask what the plan for reopening the pub is?

A cynic might suggest a falling down pub in a prime location would be ripe for redevelopment as houses which would make a lot on the market - but I’m no cynic.

I have every faith the new owner plans to redevelop this local gem - but it would be wonderful if whoever they are could explain perhaps here in March) what their plan is?

Ed King


Letter - Sue Blackshaw - FebMar 2025

Bus Shelters

As a frequent user of the buses locally, I am confused about the messages given over for the use of public transport If bus use is to be encouraged then bus shelters must be part of that provision. At many stops in Woodstock there is no shelter or seat, and the condition of existing shelters is bleak. I see that some shelters are to be given attention, very sad that it has taken so long to get this done.

Many times I pass people waiting at Hensington Gate stop and the current shelter is not big enough for the numbers there at prime time; the Perspex is very shabby and damaged. What view do visitors take away of our town, but also how does this encourage use by local residents.

The number 7 service is extremely useful but a further downside is the lack of bus shelters in Kidlington for the homeward wait. There is no shelter centrally for those coming north, and it seems very remiss that there are none in either direction at the Exeter Hall information hub. No seat and no shelter. Electronic time display would be of huge benefit at every bus-stop; not everyone has access to smart phone apps.

A joined-up plan should be expected - shame on those who are not supportive or pro-active in working towards clean and useable and effective public transport and waiting areas.

On a recent trip to Queensland, I used the vast array of buses which served the suburbs and beyond - fares were 50c (25p) for ALL journeys within the State, for all distances. Virtually all stops had shelters and seats, even in rural areas; they want people to use buses and give a high standard and safe experience. Yes - Australia has more space - but it is very doable to improve matters here; why isn’t public transport given a higher priority?

Sue Blackshaw


Letter - Gwyn Bevan - FebMar 2025

The proposed development of Botley West Solar Farm: unanswered questions of uncertainty, food security and environmental impact*The scale of the proposed development of Botley West Solar Farm means that it escapes scrutiny by our local councils and is a matter for the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero. If that development were publicly-financed the Treasury would require it to be justified by social cost benefit analysis of the Green Book.

Private finance of Botley West means there has been exploration neither of optimism bias, given a radically uncertain future, nor comparison of costs and benefits with other sites. These fundamental requirements of the Green Book ought to be crucial in assessing that proposal.

An example of optimism bias in the face of uncertainty is that, in 2024, we paid over £300m to windfarms in Scotland not to generate electricity (because the grid could not cope with excess supply). Given the scale of the proposed developments of wind farms across the UK, will we end up paying them not to generate electricity in summer heatwaves? These are increasing in intensity as one consequence of climate change. The Botley West Acceptance Stage Glossary does not explore such future uncertainties. Our recent floods mean that its assessments of flood Risk are now out of date. Unprecedented gales can destroy solar farms. Storm Daragh destroyed the 190-acre solar farm built in Anglesey in 2022: ‘hundreds of panels were shredded and torn off their fixings … and residents living nearby now fear land contamination from shattered solar panels’.

The Botley West proposal reports that, of the land surveyed, 95% is at least of moderate agricultural quality, and 36% of good, very good or excellent quality. Climate change is reducing the productive potential of agricultural land across the world: from changes in temperature, precipitation, wind speed, crop growth cycles, frequency of extreme weather events, and patterns of pests and diseases. Another known unknown are the impacts of wars on global food supplies, e.g., in Ukraine.

The justifications for choosing the Botley West site are: that it delivers a solar farm at scale to meet increasing demand for electricity from Oxfordshire’s fast-growing economy; and its proximity to the Cowley substation minimises energy lost in transmission to the grid. But that criterion ought not be given overriding importance: it needs to be set against its losses in food security and environmental damage. The environmental damage caused by the development of Botley West is keenly felt by those living nearby. One way of estimating that damage as set out in the Green Book is that of ‘hedonic pricing’, e.g., the depreciation from the impact of a solar farm on the prices of the 10,000 houses within 1km of Botley West, which may outweigh greater losses in energy in transmission from other sites that have few houses near them.

If Botley West were publicly-financed, then the Green Book would apply and require a comparison across sites in their capabilities to secure our future supplies of both green energy and food, and environmental impacts. Does private finance mean these comparisons are not required? Gwyn Bevan Editors Comment: The author has provided references for this Letter and is happy to share them.


Letter - Hilary Brown - FebMar 2025

All act now or we could lose millions in community benefit from Botley West Solar Farm During the past 2 years, whether for, against or something in between, much has been said and written on the developer’s proposal (PVDP) for Botley West Solar Farm … there’s been much to say. We’re now at the next stage of the National Infrastructure Planning process, called ‘pre-examination’ and we’ve learnt that the suggested community benefit by PVDP has improved since the 2nd consultation from £50K to £200K per annum for the lifetime of the project. (Community benefits are financial payments which can be made by developers of energy infrastructure to local communities that will be impacted by the development and currently paid on a voluntary basis in England). It is highly likely that the proposal will be approved by the Government in one form or another and the suggested £200K has been highlighted as totally inadequate, and should be £4.2million per annum. Space here doesn’t allow me to go into detail but a figure of £5K per MW per year should be considered (£5K x 840 MW = £4.2million). This amount can be referenced and viewed – ‘the briefings and the debate on community benefits at the Houses of Parliament (October 2024)’.

I encourage all your readers, Woodstock and beyond to feedback on the derisory level of community benefit suggested. If the proposal is agreed as it stands, communities throughout our area will miss out on millions of £s over the lifetime of the project. Don’t let this be another water company story. Everyone can help this cause – search for - National Infrastructure project – then select Botley West - ‘Register an Interest’ . No need to give your view in detail at the point of registration but please register your concern over the level of community benefit … whether you agree or disagree with Botley West. You just need to give a brief summary of your opinion and the detail you can submit later.

There is more detail in Sustainable Woodstock’s February newsletter.

Hilary Brown


Letter - Blenheim Hi-Viz - FebMar 2025

Ensuring Safety in Blenheim Parkland During Dark Hours As we transition from winter to spring, the days are gradually getting longer, but it remains dark from 17:00 until around 08:00. During these hours, Blenheim Parkland experiences increased contractor vehicle movements due to ongoing renovations, including a large roof project. Unfortunately, the limited lighting makes it difficult for drivers to see pedestrians, especially those wearing dark clothing.

Blenheim Parkland is a cherished space for fitness, mental well-being, and safe routes to school. To maintain its safety, we kindly ask all park users to take precautions during dark hours. Please wear high-visibility clothing and head torches, ensure your dogs are visible and on leads, and if cycling, use front and rear lights and wear helmets Additionally, walking/running towards oncoming vehicles and avoiding headphones can help you stay aware of your surroundings.

By taking these simple steps, we can all contribute to keeping Blenheim Parkland a safe and welcoming place for everyone. Thank you.

Gavin Donnelly - Security Manager, Blenheim Palace


Letter - Dave Carrington - Feb Mar 2025

**Town Council Christmas Expenditure((

I would like to share with you the text of a letter which I hand delivered to the Town Council today.

I am writing as a concerned resident of Woodstock to seek clarity on the expenditure allocated for Christmas trees and Christmas lights this year. While I appreciate the effort to create a festive atmosphere for our community, I am curious about the costs involved, particularly in light of current economic challenges. Specifically, I would like to understand: 1. The total spent on five standalone Christmas trees – can you confirm it was £4,5000 please? 2. How these costs were justified in the council’s budget, and who negotiated with the supplier? 3. The Minutes show that £11,500 was approved for the original lights - can you confirm how much the Council actually paid the contractor? 4. Please can you explain the lack of adequate communication between two Councils about the pollarding, and what steps you are both making to make sure that this doesn’t happen again? I fully support initiatives that bring joy and community spirit, but I believe transparency and responsible spending are equally important, especially when other essential services might be under pressure. I would greatly appreciate it if you could provide details or direct me to where this information is available. I look forward to your response.

Dave Carrington


Letter - Themis - Feb/Mar 2025

Botley West I have registered with the planning inspectorate to have a say on the ‘Botley West Solar’ proposal and have made the following comments - I am happy for you to reproduce this in the next Woodstock and Bladon News edition to encourage more to object in this way: Dear Sirs, I object most strenuously to this proposal which, through the heinous and liberal use of greenwashing, would trash our environment (already the most depleted natural environment in Europe) purportedly to save it. Our decreasing natural environment belongs to all of us, not a handful of avaricious and greedy individuals who simply wish to take advantage of ill thought out politically expedient and dangerous policies.

I object to this for the following key reasons:

  1. The sheer scale of this proposal is testament to the fact that this is no altruistic exercise by the landowners but a money grab which would benefit a handful of individuals, mainly senior directors and beneficiaries of Blenheim. The millions of ordinary residents and visitors to what was once a green and pleasant land would be faced with a vast industrialised Oxfordshire landscape bereft of any nature.
  1. Tenant farmers have already been evicted by the Blenheim landowners in anticipation of the green light to this industrialisation of vast swathes of the countryside - farming land is being given over to the unnecessary industrialisation of valuable and needed farm land: we cannot concrete our farms in order to import our food: food security is paramount, let alone the lunacy of the environmental footprint of importing food from abroad.
  1. The environmental impact of manufacturing, transporting (from China) and eventually disposing of this type of solar panel equipment is hugely destructive - it is environmentally absurd and unsound.
  1. New solar panel technology is advancing rapidly - the type of solar panel proposed here, in their millions, is already obsolete: ultra thin (2 - 3 mm) solar panels are already in development and will have the capacity to be practically invisible and cover roofs and windows with minimal visual or environmental impact. This technology is already proven and in development.
  1. There would be no impact on consumer energy prices should this power plant be built - electricity is sold to the grid and will have no impact on prices.
  1. It has been shown scientifically that bats cannot fly over solar covered fields - the consequences of this are severe from an ecological standpoint; it is also noteworthy that individuals are prohibited from obtaining planning permission of any homes or extensions that have any impact on bats: this would be a glaring 'them and us' situation where one rule applies to 'them' and one to 'us'.
  1. The glare from such enormous swathes of glass would interfere with flights to and from Oxford airport, and interfere with our views and mental health.
  1. It has been shown repeatedly that we, as human beings, need the natural world around us and it is imperative for our health and mental well being - this county in particular, appears to have been earmarked for concretisation: housing, college scientific parks, reservoirs, football stadiums, electricity pylons, wind 'farms', and now what is left of any green grass appears to be targeted with insidious solar 'farms' (ie power stations) which would unacceptably deplete what is left of our natural habitat and that of all the wildlife that would be exterminated.
  1. Even if solar was the way forward (which is extremely debatable in this country), then solar panels can be placed on millions of acres of industrial, office and retail roof spaces: warehouses, office buildings, petrol stations, industrial and scientific parks etc would all benefit first for their own use and sell the surplus to the grid, all leased by the government's 'GB Energy'. This model has already been started by eg Plymouth Council with solar panels on petrol stations. It is a 'no brainer' solution to the solar panel question without the industrialisation of our countryside with the permanent and catastrophic effects that would have - it would be criminally irresponsible of the government to trash what is left of our depleted natural world when an obvious solution is glaringly in front of them, and has been suggested to them.

For the above and other reasons, it is imperative for this proposal to be stopped in its entirety and a rethink along the lines mentioned above be done before our beautiful countryside is irreversibly and unnecessarily damaged beyond repair, all for the avaricious benefit of one landowner and politically irresponsible politicians who will long be out of office when such damage is done.

Thank you

Themis Avraamides


Letter - Jo Lamb - FebMar 2025

“Why on earth should anyone care about what is going on within Woodstock Town Council?”

After all, surely it is so much easier to let ‘them’ just get on with it, leaving the rest of ‘us’ to get on with our lives undisturbed by local politics.

But should it be like this; with the division of the ‘them’ and ‘us’? Local government has always encouraged a level of participation by its electors by allowing a section within Council meetings for members of the public to express any concerns they may have to Councillors at that meeting. This public participation is an essential component of democracy, being the means of communication between a Council and the public it is meant to represent Another benefit of public participation is that it aids the transparency and openness which all local councils, Woodstock included, both profess to follow and aim to foster.

Since Woodstock’s new representatives took office in May 2024, the Standing Orders governing Council procedure have been altered stage by stage, the end result being a virtual airbrushing of the significance of public participation We now have a new ‘Protocol’ for public participation, which was quietly voted through by a mere 6 Councillors during an ETC (Extraordinary Town Council) meeting, last November.

The current position in Woodstock is that the public participation session is only permitted once the Mayor has suspended the Council meeting. The public’s session is now considered as extraneous to the meeting itself. Therefore, the Minutes of the Council meeting no longer contain any detail of what concerns are expressed by the public, nor do they name the speaker; and hence the airbrushing to which I refer.

Councillors are now being muffled too. They are no longer allowed to seek any clarification from the speaker on a concern raised by him/her in public participation.

Added to these limitations, Woodstock’s town council meetings are not filmed nor recorded on line, to enable both easier accessibility to its meetings by the public, as well as the transparency and accountability of Council to its local community. The facilities already exist within the Town Council to enable these modern communication methods.

There is an ‘Owl’ device, perched in the centre of the Councillors during meetings, which was purchased by the previous Administration precisely to enable such recording and filming. Sadly, the Owl has been both gagged and blindfolded over recent months.

Contrast Woodstock Town Council (WTC), with West Oxfordshire District Council (WODC).

WODC allows a full 30 minutes for its public sessions (ie, double the amount of time allowed by Woodstock). Each WODC speaker is given a maximum of 5 minutes in which to speak (cf 3 minutes in Woodstock). WODC’s participation sessions also take place within its meetings. They are not suspended. WODC meetings are also filmed, recorded and made openly available for all to see. WODC Councillors are allowed to seek clarification of any matter raised by a speaker during public participation. Public submissions are fully minuted in WODC Minutes. All this is considered “best practice” for local parishes to follow. Most (if not all), do. Woodstock falls short. It does not adhere to best practice as so defined. Why not? Woodstock needs to facilitate true transparency, accessibility and accountability to its electorate. It cannot continue to exclude its voters from raising concerns within Council meetings. What does it have to fear by its imposition of these controls? Surely there can be no justification for this within modern democracy.

I very much hope that our 3 newly elected town councillors are able to make a difference to the future workings of our Town Council. I fear they may have a long and uphill battle. Let’s hope they have the requisite stamina!

Jo Lamb


Letter - Stephen Westaby - April 2025

Botley West and aircraft safety

I am pleased that Oxford Airport and RAF Brize Norton have expressed concerns about a solar industrial site in proximity to their runways. I have a different but complementary perspective having been on site at two fatal air crashes on Bladon Heath. One followed an aborted landing, whilst the other occurred soon after takeoff. On the first occasion I attempted to enter the aircraft amidst a sea of leaking fuel but was advised to step away when the airport fire truck arrived. When safety was established the Ambulance Officer asked me to determine whether the pilot or passengers could be resuscitated. Sadly they had already succumbed to chest and head injuries though I doubt the deaths were immediate

When I reached the second crash in a field close to my home the cockpit was ablaze and it was clear that there were no survivors. Such events are rare but when they do occur the emergency services need rapid access to the site Oxford Airport has one of the busiest flight schools in the country whilst Brize Norton may one day be involved in conflict. If so, damaged military aircraft may attempt to land safely. Thus my point is rather simple. Should aircraft crash land in a sea of solar panels, timely rescue will not be possible. Nor can misjudged or aborted landings be made safely in a conglomerate of metal and glass. I suspect the airports would rather not express these dismal concerns but who in their right minds would create additional danger.

There is only one answer to that question!

Professor Stephen Westaby, Bladon

PS: Since submitting this letter there has been news that Schiphol, Holland’s principal commercial airport, has been forced to shut down a main runway at certain times of the day when the sun is shining, through glare from nearby solar panels.

Obviously this is to avoid danger to approaching aircraft which may also accrue from heat and air turbulence. These risks have been known about for some time, so as a bioengineer(PhD) as well as a surgeon, I am dismayed that it has not been raised by Botley West in their consultation process. Why risk a civil disaster for yet more solar panels? Should we accept the consultation process as valid, and do we have a government prepared to take these aspects seriously? They acknowledge that only one percent of UK land needs to be committed to solar so why devastate a huge area of agricultural and green belt land between two busy airports?

Editors Note: Professor Westaby performed more than 12,000 heart operations on both adults and children and achieved the world’s longest survivor with any type of artificial heart. He published 350 scientific papers and 14 textbooks, three of which were on major injuries. From Oxford he promoted the development of regional trauma centres for the UK with air ambulance retrieval. His books for the public, ‘Fragile Lives, The Knife’s Edge, The Trauma Chronicles and Surgeons, Saints and Psychopaths’, have been translated into many languages.


Letter - Helen Stephenson - May 2025

Dear Editor

Emma Parkin (nee Pollock)

In 2022 my friend, Emma, suffered the most unimaginable tragedy when her nine year old son, Sam, died suddenly from a rare stomach disorder.

Sam was a very creative boy - talented at art - and soon after his death, his mother instinctively started doing what he’d loved to do; forage in nature to create pictures and models. It became Emma’s therapy and made her feel closer to Sam.

Taking inspiration and materials from things she’d grown, found or foraged, she began to make original, imaginative and eco-friendly gifts, using sustainable materials wherever possible, which she now sells on Etsy Emma was brought up in Bladon and we first met when she was at the village playgroup in the late 1970’s with my daughter. Our families became good friends, and remain so to this day, which is why I’d like to help her by spreading the word.

Please look at her website: https://www.etsy.com/shop/littlefacecreations/ £1 from every sale goes to a fund that supports charities and causes that Sam cared about.

Helen Stevenson


Letter - Hilary Brown - May 2025

Dear Editor

A petition for the benefit of communities in which we all live.

I spoke at the recent Woodstock Annual Town Meeting and encouraged residents to better understand community benefits* related to the Botley West Solar Farm. A comment made at the meeting and on social media since (We Love Woodstock) suggests a few are still unaware that community benefit has no bearing at all on the Government’s decision. Whether you welcome the Botley West Solar Farm, have serious concerns about it, or want to STOP it - one thing is certain: IF the Government does give approval, it will generate clean energy … and huge profits for the investors and developers. And yet local people are being offered so little despite this enormous and profitable scheme. We were shocked to learn that there is no legal requirement yet for a community benefit fund for these schemes in England. By any comparison, the £200K per annum suggested by the developers is wholly inadequate given its size, proximity to communities and the reasons listed by STOP BotleyWest campaigners. We think 2% of the project’s revenue approximately £1-2 million each year) should be invested directly in local communities. This will be for the lifetime of the proposal (35-40 years) and that would mean more where it’s most needed.

We are calling on everyone including those who want to stop the development to sign the petition inthe event the proposal is approved. The petition calls on Blenheim to do what they can to influencethe developers so local people have a fairer share of the profits. The petition is NOT anti-Blenheim, butevidence is needed that you care about the community benefit. You do not have to live in Woodstock to sign, as we hope that speaking out can lead to a national policy for these schemes upand down the country. So, please feel free to share the petition far-and-wide … please take a moment, read the petition and hopefully sign it: https://www.lowcarbonhub.org/make-botley-westfair/ * Renewable energy companies often establish funds that provide financial support to local communities. These funds can be used for a variety of purposes, such as funding local projects, supporting community groups, or improving local infrastructure.

Hilary Brown, Sustainable Woodstock


Letter - Jane Askam

Dear Editor,

Electrical Infrastructure or Farmland?

As you know, I recently re-visited Woodstock and we met for a catch-up. I was interested to see your impressive local magazine but very upset to learn about the threat to Blenheim's beautiful and historic surroundings posed by the 4,000 acre Botley West Solar Farm project. Is nowhere sacred? We face the same issues in Lincolnshire where I live, actually far worse. Not only do we have to contend with the 2,000 acre Heckington Fen Solar Park, owned by Dale Vince's Ecotricity - this is going ahead despite strong local opposition, including from the County Council, and despite the recent discovery of decades worth of gas fields in the county. We are also fighting against the construction of 140km of 50 metre high pylons between Grimsby and Walpole, which would decimate our beautiful countryside.

My heart goes out to you all. Good luck in the fight!

Jane Askam


Letter - Naomi Richards

Dear Editor,

The Black Prince

It is said that Oxford is a summer city; brickwork and the greenery shine brightly in the sun and create a magical atmosphere. I think the same can be said of Woodstock; and the recent VE Day celebrations saw Woodstock at its best. The atmosphere was one of geniality, and there was a real sense of togetherness. There was only one thing missing: the chance to celebrate sitting at familiar wooden tables next to the Glyme or inside the ever-welcoming bar at the Black Prince.

I often pass the Black Prince and see that someone has put a Union Jack flag in one of theupper windows - perhaps a makeshift curtain? I wonder what it hides. The Black Prince was a focal point for the community for years, and then suddenly it went dark. Rumours still circulate - the new owner wants to turn it into flats or there has been some sort of financial wrongdoing. Nobody seems to know.

So my questions are simple: when are we getting our beloved pub back? Can someone actually tell us what is going on?

Naomi Richards


Letter - Giles Lewis - AugSept 2025

Dear Editor,

Climate Alarmism

In the last issue of this magazine an article from Sustainable Woodstock (Page 15, July 2025 issue) opened with quotes on climate change from Calum Miller MP and Prof. Alex Rogers respectively, which included the following: 'I regard it as probably the greatest generational challenge that our generation faces' (CM), and 'Climate change is a global emergency and the results of ignoring it will be nothing short of a calamity on the scale of a world war for humanity and for the environment' (AR).

I am no longer surprised by wild overstatements of this kind on this subject. Climate alarmism has become an ideology, fervid and brooking no discussion, let alone dissent. But in my opinion, and the opinion of many more scientists than is generally acknowledged, statements such as these are not founded in science. They carry national economic risk and need to be challenged.

When I wrote an article for your magazine criticising Botley West in this vein (Follow the Money, Page 7, May 2023 Issue) I was requested by the previous Editor to supply all my supporting sources, which I did Perhaps this admirable rigour should equally be applied to expressions of climate alarmism?

Giles Lewis


Letter - Gwyn Bevan - AugSept 2025

Dear Editor

Yes to solar energy, but no to Botley West Solar Farm

The Woodstock and Bladon News has fulfilled a vital role in the debate over Botley West Solar Farm. Given the scale and frequency of catastrophic floods and fires caused by changes in the climate, virtually all those who oppose Botley West Solar Farm recognise the urgency of changing to green energy. The grounds for our opposition are that we have not seen a convincing case for destruction of the land we cherish around our homes. In July 2025, the excellent article by Professor Stephen Westaby focused on the risk that development poses to safe use of our local airport. But for me, what was most troubling, was this reported exchange: Question to a representative of the Photovolt Development Partners (PVDP) at a village consultation event: ‘Why cover thousands of acres of Oxfordshire green belt and agricultural land with solar panels given that there are abundant sites elsewhere?’ Answer: ‘Because that’s what Blenheim gave us’.

The private finance of Botley West Solar Farm means that the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero has not been required to undertake option appraisal as required for public capital by the Treasury’s Green Book (1). There has been no development of a long list, evaluation of to determine a short list, and evaluation of the short list to justify the recommended option. The Green Book requires these evaluations to identify constraints and dependencies and critical success factors and undertake social cost benefit analysis. That begins by evaluating options of criteria that can be quantified and given monetary values (e.g. costs of construction). But Green Book emphasises the importance of evaluation options of criteria where quantification is problematic and there are no direct way of giving them a monetary value: e.g., impact on enjoyment of the countryside. I could not find in the Green Book any recommendation for choosing a site because it was offered by a large local landowner.

Gwyn Bevan

Reference: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/the-green-book-appraisal-and-evaluation-in-centralgovernment.


Letter - Anonymous - AugSept 2025

Dear Editor

Mock Mayor

Nothing could ever put a dampener on Mock Mayor celebrations, held this year on 19th July. Callum Miller, our local MP, was put into the dock of the mock court, where he dealt with good-natured charges with charm and humour.

This, however, was not the highlight of the mock court proceedings.

The last defendant in the dock was a rather desperate-looking Christmas tree. It was accused and found guilty of extorting £5000 from Woodstock Town Council. What was most notable was not the tree as such, but the absence of a single member of Woodstock Town Council to speak on the matter. Despite a request sent in advance, no councillors volunteered to attend the mock court, even though at least one member was seen by many to be enjoying the proceedings. In the Town Council meeting held three days later the mayor said that she had messaged organisers of the Mock Mayor and expressed a hope that it wouldn’t rain.

It didn’t rain; and in fact the sunshine got stronger throughout the afternoon. Perhaps a sign that in matters of council spending and Christmas trees, more light should be shone on the issue.

Yours sincerely, Anonymous


Letter - Chris Coe - AugSept 2025

Dear Editor,

Doctors Surgery

I assume that all residents have received a letter from Councillor Grant about the Doctors’ surgery and asking us for our thoughts on locating it at the old Thames Valley Police (TVP) site.

I replied by receipt (2 August) about the content which, in my view, didn’t disclose all the information needed for residents to provide a considered response. Here are my thoughts: You acknowledge that the landowner (Blenheim) does not support the use of this locafon following advice from a specialist consulting architect. What you failed to mention is that the TVP location isn't supported by the Doctors either - 'A further meeting with Dr Becker noted that he was strongly against this site' (as reported on page 14 of Woodstock and Bladon News July 2025). The TVP site was also ruled out at the first Town Meeting about the surgery held at the church in November 2024’.

Another key fact, missing from your leger, is that the currently refused planning applicafon for the TVP site is being appealed to The Planning Inspectorate. Coincidentally I received a detailed ###Letter today about the appeal from McCarthy & Stone's advisors which anyone commenting on the plan will also have received. I opposed the original application and I will consider, with interest, the revised plans and the approach that is being taken to the appeal by McCarthy & Stone.

Some of the points raised in your leger under 'Motion 1 a) to g)' have no supporting evidence and point d) ['the site is already on a bus route to accommodate the 60% of patients living outside the Town'] implies that all the outlying villages in the surgery's catchment are served by a bus to Woodstock. Even if they are, and many are not, getting a bus at a suitable time for an appointment can be very difficult as anyone living in a village can testify. Driving is already a necessity for many patients.

It appears that despite the Town Council either not understanding or explaining why the landowner, the Doctors and the wider 'Stakeholder Steering Group' are all opposed to the TVP site, the Town Council want to spend time (and presumably taxpayers’ money) opposing it and encouraging us to do likewise. As noted above, there is also an appeal underway which, whether we like it or not, could be successfully determined in a matter of months making residents opinions irrelevant should it be successful for the Appellant.

I would personally love to be able to continue to walk to a surgery but, if the combined expertise of the Doctors, the Integrated Care Board, OCC, and WODC are opposed to the TVP site, then they have my support in finding somewhere suitable for all the patients not just the 40% who live in Woodstock.

I very much look forward to the next Town Meeting (November 2025?) and to be able to hear from the Steering Group on what progress is being made.

Chris Coe


Letter - Anonymous pilot

Dear Editor,

London Kidlington Airport close to Solar Panels

I am a Flying Instructor who has taught trainee pilots from Oxford Airport at Kidlington - an excellent training centre for novice pilots, many of whom go on to careers in commercial aviation. During my time instructing there, I was in no doubt that it is one of the safest learning environments for many reasons, not least the surrounding countryside that offers a reassuring choice of emergency landing areas in the event of any technical issues.

With safety in mind, I am dismayed to see that the Botley West developer proposes to install thousands of solar panels so close to an exceptionally active airfield with mixed traffic, from learner pilots in single engine aircraft to helicopters and the largest of private jets.

In response to a recent engine-related emergency landing in a field just beyond the end of the southerly runway, the developers have removed a ‘wedge’ of the proposed solar panels roughly in the direction that an aircraft would be pointing, with the aim of making any engine failure after take-off safer. While this is obviously a positive move, it unfortunately assumes that all such engine failure incidents happen in the textbook fashion, which unfortunately they don't.

The standard departure procedure for single-engined light aircraft is to climb to 1000 feet above sea level before a right turn along the railway line and continuing to climb to no higher than 2000 feet until the aircraft is at least 5 miles from the airport. During this take-off phase the pilot has to be aware of potential engine failure and be prepared to take very decisive action.

Most training aircraft can glide without the engine with a descent rate of approximately 500 feet per minute, giving a maximum time of approximately 3.5 minutes for the pilot to identify a suitable field, manoeuvre the aircraft safely towards the field, carry out essential security drills, potentially deal with passengers, and make Air Traffic Control aware of the situation.

This routine is practiced many times during training until it becomes instinctive, however the one thing the pilot has no control over, no matter how good the training, is the choice of available landing sites. To cover so many fields close to the airport and the pilot training area with solar panels would severely restrict the options available in this situation.

I don’t wish to overstate the risks of an engine failure as it is fortunately a rare event. However, options need to be available and should the unthinkable happen, I have always been satisfied as a Flying Instructor that those options exist at Oxford Airport.

Another important consideration - the physical effects of large numbers of solar panels close to the landing/take-off areas cannot be understated. In hot weather they can create serious turbulence and glare which can very easily upset the approach of a light aircraft, particularly for a student or low-hours pilot. I have instructed at other airfields close to solar farms, much smaller than the proposed Botley West plans, and have had to take emergency control from a student pilot as the invisible thermals suddenly disrupt a nice approach.

One final point: I have previously worked as a member of the emergency services and the thought of a rescue operation to retrieve injured people from the midst of a solar farm fills me with dread. I struggle to think of how it could be achieved without severe risk to all concerned, including the emergency responders.

Anonymous

*Editor's Note: The identity of the anonymous letters, both local residents who wish to remain anonymous, have been validated by the Editor.


Letter - Steve Westaby

Dear Editor,

Clear and present danger: A sequel to 'Lives before loot.'

I am grateful to the veteran flight instructor for sharing his personal experiences of the danger of solar panels in proximity to airports.

At the same time a 'battle royal' has erupted in the Dutch aviation industry which has clear implications for West Oxfordshire. The controversy is even more relevant now that British Airways will soon relocate their pilot training to Oxford Airport.

In spring this year Amsterdam’s Schiphol Airport was forced to close two of its main runways between 10am and noon through intense glare from nearby solar panels. As you will see from the illustration the 100 hectare site is some distance from the airport perimeter and diminutive in comparison with the proposed 1000 hectare Botley West development. Yet it has created havoc. As well as causing severe air traffic disruption it has impacted the local community through noise pollution when aircraft are diverted over residential areas. When the costs to Schiphol exceeded €330 million and further closures were predicted for the autumn, the solar developer was taken to court It transpired that the local municipality Haarlemmermeer had been warned in advance that glare posed risks for both pilots and control tower before planning permission was granted. So now they were also in the firing line. The court’s judgement was that the developer, De Groene Energie Corridor had caused a situation that, to quote, “is a severe threat to flight safety”. Accordingly the judge ordered the company to immediately remove 78,000 of the offending panels by September 1st . A penalty of €1 million will be inflicted if the work is not completed by that time with a further €500,000 for each day that the panels remain afterwards. The developer made clear that this would bankrupt them but the National airline KLM entered the debate stating that the disruption had cost them many millions so they would sue if all the panels were not dismantled immediately. The Dutch Airline Authority is now overseeing the deconstruction of the whole site and insisting that the original permit be revoked.

Whether our own Government Planning Inspectorate wants to take the same risks remains to be seen. West Oxfordshire District Council clearly don’t. The Schiphol experience now sets an important legal precedent. Discarding the warnings has been financially catastrophic for both airport and developer. So are we on the same planet? What are the differences between Amsterdam and Oxford? Firstly the Dutch site is a fraction of the size of the Botley West proposal. We are anticipating 1000 hectares of metal, glass and high wire fences between Oxford Airport and Brize Norton, one of the UK’s principle RAF bases. Second, the pilots flying commercial jets into Schiphol are experienced and assisted by co-pilots. In stark contrast, Oxford Airport is an exceptionally busy training school with novices flying small, and in some cases, aging, single engine aircraft on the same runway day and night. The flight instructor outlined the multiple dangers including blinding glare, bird displacement from Bladon Heath with the risk of engine strike, thermal currents from hot panels and potential disruption of radar systems at the RAF base. And it goes without saying, the vast expanse of panels would severely restrict emergency landing options and access for the emergency services.

In April 2024 well in advance of the Photovolt Development Partners submission for government approval, an article entitled 'Balancing solar energy generation and pilot safety at airports' was published in the scientific press. This contains the statement “solar reflections can impact pilots and cause safety concerns through glint and glare”. The research employed a Solar Glare Hazard Analysis Tool (SGHAT) widely used in the air industry and formally endorsed by the US Federal Aviation Administration. Given that the Botley West site abuts closely upon Oxford Airport should these important issues not have been shared by Photovolt Development Partners with interested parties? Similarly the World Health Organisation has advised a 1.2 mile (2 km) gap between residential buildings and solar panels.

As a result of the airport’s concerns a derisory 10 hectare wedge of panels was removed at the end of the runway. The purpose was to mitigate against emergency landings in the event of engine failure but this fails to address the multitude of other potential hazards. The ‘Schiphol precedent’ would see all panels removed from proximity to both Oxford Airport and Brize Norton which probably means the development in its entirety.

It’s time to ‘get real.’ The UK contributes just 1% to global emissions so what does the widespread decimation of rural Britain achieve? Solar sites are proliferating rapidly in an unregulated manner driven by the uncertain future for farmers. For sub-50-megawatt developments (less than 100 hectares) national planning permission is not required.

Landowners benefit from £1,200/acre/year whilst the operator sells electricity at prices indexed to gas generation irrespective of solar’s negligible input costs. A 100 hectare, 50 megawatt site can generate £3 million annually with profit over 40 years reaching £120 million. Multiply that by 10 for Botley West’s earnings and you will have little doubt about their motivation. In the meantime consumers see their energy bills rise not fall. The National Grid warns of oversupply where producers have to be paid not to generate power so this is not about ‘saving the planet’. Only this week, Nikkei Asia reported that major Chinese solar panel makers have posted huge losses in the first half of the year due to production overcapacity so the industry faces mounting pressure to cut output.

The time to address these issues is now, not when solar panels already cover West Oxfordshire. One solar related aviation event could have huge financial implications given the Schiphol experience. Should you consider these to be singular and radical views I can tell you that there are four other Professors of Medicine or Surgery in Bladon, all of whom share the same concerns.

Professor Stephen Westaby


Letter - Sam Dawson

Dear Editor

Woodstock Town Council

I note with regret on Woodstock Town Council website the resignation of Nicholas Melliss, formerly a Town Councillor. This is particularly disappointing as he was only elected to the Council on 1st May 2025 - a very short tenure. He may, of course, have entirely unanticipated and personal reasons for resigning; in which case, I wish him well.

The turnover of Town Councillors at Woodstock seems to be a matter of grave concern however, if for no other reason than the cost of holding by-elections. It does cause one to wonder whether there is something else that triggered his resignation. I understand that now 4 Councillors have resigned in the last 18 months (3 of them at the same time and only 2 months after being elected), and 1 Mayor left after only 6 months in position. What is going on? Why do new Councillors leave so quickly, after only a few meetings rather than staying on the Town Council? Why is the Town Council not doing more to flag this vacancy and encourage a by-election to bring new blood on board? I understand that if no by-election is called for the position will either remain vacant, or someone will be coopted on by existing Councillors - neither of these is particularly democratic! The Council have posted about the vacancy on their website and, no doubt, have put up a notice in the Town Hall.

Whilst meeting minimum requirements, it brings to mind the search for information from his council by Arthur Dent of “The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy” - he found it “on display in the bottom of a locked filing cabinet stuck in a disused lavatory with a sign on the door saying “Beware of the Leopard”.

The Town Council recently saw fit to pay to put leaflets through everyone’s door to highlight their concern regarding the Doctors’ Surgery - they can promote something when they want to. I don’t think they have even flagged the Councillor vacancy on Facebook - which is free! I would be interested to hear what others think about what is happening at the Town Council.

Sam Dawson, by email


Letter - Jonathan Ford - Oct 2025

Dear Editor,

Is climate change the greatest issue our generation faces?

I refer to Giles Lewis’ letter in the August/September edition of WOBL.

The second quote he uses is from Prof. Alex Rogers’ excellent autobiography ‘The deep’ in which he describes his remarkable work protecting our oceans. I recommend it. The quote is part of a paragraph explaining a key reason for writing the book. The full paragraph is as follows:

‘I sincerely hope that by reading this book and seeing the damage being done to our oceans by warming, acidification and deoxygenation that you will support any efforts to reduce our dependence on hydrocarbons. Whether it be through switching off the lights when a room is not in use, cycling to work or writing to your political representative, any action we take is significant. Climate change is a global emergency and the results of ignoring it will be nothing short of a calamity on the scale of a world war for humanity and for the environment. The warnings from our geological history are clear and mass extinction will be knocking on the door of the ocean very soon unless we can get carbon emissions under control quickly.’

Whilst I agree that these words are alarming, they are not wild overstatements as Giles suggests. Year on year scientists are providing more evidence and speaking with more clarity. In terms of sources, I refer Giles and your other readers to the following:

  • University of Reading’s Climate Stripes - a simple graphic showing the rise in temperatures year on year since 1850.
  • The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change’s turgid document wrigen by leading climate scienfsts from around the world - ‘Climate Change 2023: Synthesis Report.’
  • If your readers are looking for empirical evidence of the impact of climate change, I suggest typing ‘climate change and the insurance industry’ into a search engine

While I do think that Alex Rogers has been alarmist regarding BotleyWest I do not believe this is the case in this quote.

Climate change mitigation is urgent and deeply important. Well done Alex for joining others in sounding the alarm I would be pleased to discuss these issues with Giles (and others). It is essential that decisions about climate change mitigation is based on as full an understanding of the facts as possible. Whether these facts are comfortable or not we should embrace them and make any necessary decisions and proportional actions. Based on the information available it is reasonable to say that significant sacrifices will be needed if we are going to pass on to future generations as wonderful a world as we have received from those who have gone before us. If any of your readers would like to meet to discuss these issues and how we could best respond to them, I would like to hear from them. I feel called by God to get involved in responding to climate change, and perhaps this is true for you too. My telephone number is 01993 898880.

I wish Giles and all your readers well.

Jonathan Ford


Letter - Nick Melliss resignation

Dear Editor

And another one bites the dust…

With apologies to Queen, the rock group who wrote the song, not the monarch.

Why is it that - out of the four new Town Councillors elected in 2025 - two have already resigned? And in 2024, the three Town Councillors that were new in that year also resigned. Why can’t Woodstock Town Council retain its Councillors? Is it something in the Town Hall water? The Oxford Mail reported last year of a “sinister culture”, (OM 22/11/2024).

Obviously, I cannot speak for any of the others, but as one of the Councillors who resigned I can perhaps give a few answers. I think everyone in the town would like to know why their new councillors don’t seem to last more than a few months.

  • The Town Council has no system or method for listening and responding to residents’ concerns. Council meefngs work from an agenda which is drawn up by the Mayor and the Town Clerk. Residents and Councillors actually make no impact on that agenda. I set up fortnightly Councillor surgeries in Woodstock Library so anyone could come along and raise issues with me. After three or four surgeries I felt a fraud because I couldn’t respond to those issues, not meaningfully anyway.
  • The Town Council has no system for self-assessment or self-improvement. When things go wrong, and they are going wrong, no Councillor says “Hey, wait a minute, this shouldn’t happen, we were wrong here.” So it isn’t possible to put things right when they do go wrong.
  • Financial incompetence. The Council is wealthy. It owns several properties in Woodstock worth about £9million overall and has about £400,000 in its current bank account. Yet it refuses to spend money where it should. So, for instance, there is no disabled access to the Town Hall. It could also, years ago, have financed a new Health Centre but that would have required more skill and know-how than the Council possesses or cares to bring in.

If you are still in doubt about whether the Council is dysfunctional, think of the Woodstock Surgery. At the moment new Health Centres are being built across the UK. It is bonanza time for Health Centres. Wallingford have submitted plans to their District Council for a new Health Centre, though their existing one looks much better than Woodstock’s and is more recent. It will be built and financed by Berkeley Homes, perhaps not the most generous of developers, who will sell it back to the doctors in Wallingford for a nominal £1.

There are companies out there who will build a new health centre for you; they’ll finance it, plan it, build it and probably run it with the NHS. But not in Woodstock. OK, it now looks as if we’ll have a new Health Centre, possibly on the Owen Mumford site, but not because of the Town Council.

The problem is that if the Town Council is dysfunctional then things don’t get done. Woodstock Surgery is a good example of this. If things don’t get done then people suffer. As I’m disabled, I am sorry I couldn’t do more for disabled people.

Woodstock needs good Councillors. They do matter and they can make a difference, but not the current lot, with admittedly a few exceptions, and not how they are set up at the moment.

Nick Melliss


Letter - Gwen Mason - Nov 2025

Dear Editor,

Woodstock Town Council

The letter from former Town Councillor Nick Melliss in the last magazine has prompted me to write to you On 15th September 2004 I resigned from Woodstock Town Council and I give you a quote from my letter "For the last twelve years I have always been referred to as a Councillor and Mayor for the people of Woodstock. On Monday evening the people of Woodstock voted overwhelmingly for four motions put to them at the Town Meeting Last night the Council ignored all the motions thereby treating the electorate with contempt. Therefore I feel I can no longer carry on as a member of a Council that is failing to carry out the wishes of the people." I believe after twenty one years nothing has changed on the Town Council, and I can see why so many new councillors have resigned.

Gwen Mason, Former Councillor and Mayor


Letter - Giles Lewis - Nov 2025

Dear Editor,

Climate Change

I refer to Jonathan Ford`s letter in the October edition of WOBL, which was in turn a response to mine in the August/September edition.

I note that Jonathan feels called by God to get involved in responding to climate change. It is therefore possible that I might face the same difficulties as did Charles Darwin in deploying rational and scientific arguments, particularly as climate alarmism often assumes some unwelcome aspects of religiosity. For many, it is a moral issue, described in appropriate terms: 'sacrifices' must be made; a 'climate denier' is 'evil' and a 'heretic' and should 'recant'. The language used is eerily reminiscent of witch hunting in the sixteenth and seventeenth century when crop failures caused by climate cooling following the Medieval Warm period were blamed on malign human intent Jonathan assumes that his God wants us to fight climate change when the world's climate has been changing since He first made it. After the Medieval Warm, temperatures fell far enough in the 17th and 18th centuries for frost fairs to be held on the frozen Thames in London.

We must, of course, look to science not religion to try and understand climate change. But by its very nature, science - particularly climate science - is not settled. I can point to many eminent scientists, including Nobel prize winners and those from disciplines as varied and relevant as meteorology, physics, atmospheric physics, geology, palaeontology and oceanography, who do not think that warming attributable to anthropogenic CO2 is anywhere near apocalyptic.

Some serious scientists think that the demonising of CO2 is delusional. The world has undoubtedly and significantly greened recently due to rising levels of CO2. Some think that in fact we are heading for a cooling cycle. [This recalls those scientists in the 1980s who warned of imminent catastrophe due to the dawn of a new ice age!] These 'dissident' scientists may be breaking with consensus but the greatest scientists are great because they broke with consensus. "There is no such thing as consensus science. If its consensus, it isnt science. If it's science, it isn’t consensus." [Michael Crichton, CALTEC lecture, Jan 2003.] Climate change is a very big subject; it's almost absurd to even consider arguing parts of it in the ###Letters pages. What I intended in the letter that provoked Jonathan`s response was to try to cool the alarmism which is currently bringing damaging consequences. Look beyond the environmental harm that would stem from the Botley West Solar Farm at the broad insanity of the UK's net zero targets which are driving that development. They came out of institutional and governmental panic and virtue signalling rather than rational debate and careful planning.

Giles Lewis


Letter - Sam Dawson - Dec 2025

Dear Editor,

Public Toilets

I attended the Town Council meeting on 11 November and spoke at the start about the item on public toilets, asking that the Town Council:

  1. Consider asking WODC for funds to rectify the long-term neglect of their properties before WTC takes ongoing responsibility.
  1. Consult with local people and businesses to ask for feedback regarding possible closure of Brown's Lane

Ultimately, the issue was discussed and the Town Council ignored both suggestions and has declined to take on the toilets. This means Hensington Road will continue in a poor condition and Brown's Lane will close According to the stats, both sets of toilets are visited on average 7 times a day. There is well-founded speculation that this could be low due to toilets available elsewhere (museum, hospitality venues etc). In my brief speech at the start, I suggested it could also be because people (such as myself and visitors to the town) are unaware of their existence, and also that they have a track record of being 'broken' - if you’ve been let down once in an emergency, you are more likely to seek guaranteed relief elsewhere? The condition of both sets of toilets is poor after years of neglect by WODC. The cost to upgrade both sets over 10 years is estimated at c. £100k - it would seem fair for WODC to contribute some or all of the money required to rectify problems in return for WTC taking responsibility for ongoing costs, but this was not considered.

The annual income from each toilet is c. £500, whereas running costs are c. £16,500. It was interesting to note that the Mayor expressed shock that the toilets run at a loss. I am unclear why toilets should break even or run at a profit - they are an essential public service.

In my opinion, the provision of public toilets in a town is a mark of a civilised society. 14 million people in the UK have incontinence issues, 15 million menstruate, and 16 million have some kind of disability. Then there are small children who simply cannot wait.

The British Toilet Association has a campaign running to make toilet provision a legal requirement. A Royal Society for Public Health report (2019) stated: “Public toilets should be considered as essential as streetlights, roads and waste collection.” What might be the impact of closing the Brown's Lane toilets on local businesses? I hear anecdotally that when they are temporarily out-of-order this causes a significant increase in people going into at least one pub in town, purely to use their toilet facilities.

In Northern Ireland, the Derry City and Strabane District Council’s Community Toilet Scheme pays local cafes, restaurants and other businesses £300 - £800 pa to allow members of the public to use their facilities for free. This is a cost-effective way for the City to offer a much needed public service, and gives local businesses the opportunity to support the community and increase their footfall whilst their basic costs (water, electricity, toilet paper, cleaning products, staff) are covered. Why could Woodstock not investigate something similar? I am deeply frustrated that the first residents knew that an essential public service was at risk was when the agenda was published a few days before the meeting took place. Neither research into alternative ideas nor consultation with residents or businesses happened before the Town Council took a decision. They did not even pause to think, to defer the decision, in the light of my request and suggestions at the start of the meeting Do the Town Councillors really claim to represent residents?

Sam Dawson


Letter - Suzy Pearce - Dec 2025

An Editorial Visitor

My dear friend Nick - of more than fifty years and living proof that long friendships survive oceans, airlines, and questionable pub choices - arrived in Perth, Western Australia, where he set up office in heritage-listed South Fremantle. Not quite as ancient as the UK of course, but we’re trying our best down here with what little history we’ve got! In true sporting spirit, we made a beeline for The Camfield to join the Barmy Army. Nick was absolutely thrilled (not) to witness the Poms being comprehensively massacred - his words, not mine - though I’ll be politely reserving bragging rights until further notice. (Don’t worry, they’re tucked safely away for deployment at an appropriate moment.) Since the Ashes outing was cut short, I’ve taken it upon myself to show Nick the finer points of Fremantle life: the markets, the pubs, the speakeasy, and every quirky corner in between. For a supposedly 'most remote city', we’re doing our part to keep visitors entertained… even those from across the ditch. Or the hemisphere. Or… well, you know.

So if you find yourself anywhere near Perth, please do come and say hi. If it was good enough for the pommy convicts, it’s certainly good enough for you.

Suzy Pearce


Letter - Dec 2025 - Steve Westaby

Dear Editor,

Proposed new GP surgery

I regularly walked through the Accident and Emergency Department of the John Radcliffe Hospital to review cardiac emergencies. One issue was apparent both day and night. The waiting area was crammed with patients who should have been assessed and treated in GP surgeries. Some were genuinely sick, others certainly were not, and some decided to leave through frustration at the inordinate waiting times. How did the NHS reach this nightmare situation? It undoubtedly followed the Department of Health’s decision that GPs need not cover their patients out of hours or at weekends. That heralded the end game for the much valued family doctor on which the NHS was originally based.

Our health care system is unable to respond appropriately in too many respects. First and foremost, no condition benefits from waiting and our hospitals are currently overwhelmed. This introduces the issue of the Woodstock Surgery which everyone agrees is unable to meet requirements. Options for a new site are on the table but what should primary care look like for the future. Before Covid I talked with the local practice about an ambitious project that we hoped might be built on the corner of Oxford Airport (where the ‘park and ride’ is proposed) This would have provided acute care for illness or minor injuries on a 24 hour basis. An investigations department with an X-ray, ultrasound and ECG machines was included together with a pharmacy. Physiotherapy, dieticians and mental health workers were to be an integral part of the development as was a gymnasium with fitness trainers. The plans also included an outpatients department for hospital consultants to conduct appointments on a local basis and help manage chronic illness without multiple hospital visits. That said we lost the private finance group who were prepared to fund the development in the wake of the Covid debacle.

The Labour government have recently announced that they will use private monies to expand GP hubs throughout the UK. Ministers have proposed a new network of 250 'one stop shops' bringing together family doctors, dentists and pharmacies in a single location. The programme, appropriately called NHS Neighbourhood Rebuild is promised to involve innovative public and private sector partnerships. The Health Secretary now supports private companies to play a role in primary care in partnership with the fact that private hospitals treat a million surgical patients per year in an effort to meet cancer targets. Karin Smith, the Health Minister stated “Our new NHS Rebuild approach will give local health care the investment it needs, repurposing and building a new generation of Neighbourhood Health Centres across the country. It will go hand in hand with reform and efficiency, ensuring proper value for money for taxpayers”. Noble sentiments indeed when GPs are asked to do ever more without increase in practice funding or the ability to hire more staff.

With both access and parking becoming ever more taxing for the John Radcliffe I would suggest that this policy provides the perfect opportunity for Woodstock to upgrade and transform its primary care. We need substantially more ambitious facilities which our doctors and patients surely deserve. More of the same in a new building is not in anyone’s interest.

Professor Stephen Westaby