Letters to the Editor
Letters to the Editor - 2023

Letter - Tony McHugh - Feb 2023
Dear Editor,
In response to the article in the November WOBL headed 'Why is there a campaign afoot to deny the people of Old Woodstock a safe route to town, and a safe route to school ?', I have to point out that many of us residents of Old Woodstock assert that the route apparently now proposed by Blenheim, in a very late revision to its current Planning Application, is not a 'safe' route.
We have explained many times that a route across the fields now planted with saplings, soon to become trees and bushes, and on across the Glyme, will not be a safe route for children of a certain age, and also for elderly pedestrians.
I say 'of a certain age' because, whereas the children of some of the co-signatories of the article are so young as to need to be accompanied to school by a parent, older children will be walking to and from school alone, just like the solitary children one sees walking up the hill from school and from town now. I see them every day, aged from about ten years and upwards, and I can say that I would not want one of my children to be coming over the Glyme and across the growing woodland on a dark winter's afternoon, possibly in inauspicious weather. It has been put to me by one of the signatories that one cannot plan a route of the kind now proposed on the basis of just one tragic accident, such as the one in which a young girl drowned in the Glyme some years ago. But one such incident is one too many, and I would not want to be the parent of a child - or the relative of an elderly person - who became the victim of an attack. It is not as if we do not see such attacks all too often in the country as a whole.
It also needs to be said that cyclists may well wish to have such a route to town, as they would probably feel safe enough when cycling through the woodland and over the river. But they have to bear in mind the needs of pedestrians and wheelchair users.
I'm afraid that the planting of the new woodland, and the obstacle of the river where it all too frequently ßoods, together render such a path, as is currently proposed, unsafe.
Finally, the article highlights the problem of the A44 with 'Try walking it ... Try it as a slightly wobbly pensioner, one who, perhaps, does not hear so well or whose sight is failing'. Well, let those folk try as well walking down the Community Orchard and Woodland, parallel to the A44 in Old Woodstock, in the dark, or in bad weather ... Will they feel safe ? (Meant for the December issue)
Tony McHugh 42, Westland Way, Old Woodstock
Letter - Stan Scott - Feb 2023
Dear Editor,
Who better than our excellent Editor to express an opinion, as in previous issues including the last, that contributions should be made with good grace and respect for differing opinions. Our Parish magazine should surely be informative and pleasant, as well as it's stated aims of being a 'forum for discussion' and 'part of local conversations'? We did not all understand the prominent apology to the many writers of the article urging a muddy path for schoolchildren across the fields river and watermeadows, which seems rather unsafe to some, but the apology was apparently because of the inclusion of notes in brackets which should have been left out. A minor matter, not spoiling the content we might think.
But there was also an apology which seemed a bit odd, to an elected Town Councillor who had written in and had then been answered in a subsequent published letter. We surely can comment on the performance of our elected representatives, particularly when they are individually urging a particular point of view upon us? I'm all for different, interesting points of view expressed in the ###Letters page, including criticism sometimes.
Stan Scott
Letter - Ann Grant - Feb 2023
Dear Editor,
Grave concerns of desecration by defecation in Woodstock Cemeteries.
It is policy that dogs are not permitted in Council owned cemeteries. This policy serves to protect something very special; our loved one's final resting place. It was prompted many years ago by high levels of excrement in the Hensington Cemetery, as it had become a convenient place for Rover to relieve himself after a trip to the vet At a Town Council meeting last year, a motion was tabled that dogs on leads should be permitted, no supporting evidence for the change was supplied. However, there are several compelling reasons against this change: Graves become the property of the purchaser; these plots were purchased under Ts&Cs which clearly state dogs are not permitted. Many people are incredibly fearful of dogs, thus selected a dogfree cemetery, therefore to permit dogs is very unfair to those who purchased plots under these conditions and contractually dubious.
Dogs poop and whilst many owners' pick-up, many do not. Even when picked up, it is incredibly difficult to fully remove all traces of faeces, it's unacceptable to permit graves to be desecrated by defecation Some owner's pick- up and hang the full bags on trees, the disgusting spectacle of dangling poop, is not something that anyone should ever have to face in a cemetery.
Dog urine is incredibly damaging to plants, grass, ßoral tributes etc. A dog on a lead, being held by an owner on the path can and will reach the graves. Dogs don't understand that the plant they are about to cock their leg up, discolour and potentially kill, is in fact a loving tribute. Dogs bark at all manner of things, people, shadows, other dogs, the peace and quiet of this place of reßection should not be broken by doggy chatter.
Woodstock is incredibly lucky with the number of suitable green space options where dogs can be walked; defiling our cemeteries in this manner is neither necessary nor desirable.
If you'd like to have your say on this subject, Please contact the Town Clerk by Phone 01993811216; Letter; Town Hall Woodstock OX20 1SL Email info@woodstock-tc.gov.uk. Councillors contact details available on the Woodstock Council Website.
Ann Grant
Letter - Stan Scott - Mar 2023
Dear Editor,
Parking in Woodstock At the Woodstock Traffic Advisory Committee on 9 January I asked the Chairman, Councillor Andy Graham about the huge number of cheap all day parking permits to be made available to town centre residents, several Town Councillors who have voted for their own permits, and all businesses including hotels, guest houses and b&bs.
Suppose this privileged parking fills the town with static vehicles when the new parking scheme is imposed upon us (the majority voted against it) in March or April, and there are no paid spaces left for shoppers, visitors or elderly residents from the outskirts of the town or surrounding villages who need access to the churches, doctors, dentist, optician, library etc.? If there are too many permits to make the scheme work properly, I asked, who will be asked to give theirs up? If it begins to affect trade in the town and businesses suffer, what is the Plan B? Mr Dennis Allen, for 'Wake up to Woodstock' said that he and his members were also worried. No answer has been forthcoming as yet, and the scheme goes ahead. It seems a huge gamble with the success or otherwise of the town centre in the future, as a money making scheme for the County Council.
Stan Scott
Cllr Graham has been invited to respond
Letter - Anthony Glees - Mar 2023
Dear Editor, Cllr Ann Grant is absolutely right to object to dog-owners allowing their dogs to foul cemeteries in Woodstock (Feb 2023). All responsible dog-owners will concur with this. Whether the dogs are on a lead is beside the point .
Actually, no dog-owner should allow their dogs to foul any public space, full stop.
But Woodstock Town Council has made fouling much more likely than it used to be by tacitly agreeing to WODC's ill conceived 2020 plan via 'Publica', to reduce the number of litter and dog waste bins in Woodstock (49 bins sited at strategic locations throughout the Town were removed without notice, and then 'replaced' in April 2022 with only 28).
Three of the remaining bins are to be found right next to the Town Hall, within about ten feet of each other. This suits only those whose task it is to empty the contents. It is hard evidence of the lack of thought that has been given to this matter.
Other, key bins (outside the Rectory in Rectory Lane and outside what used to be Barclays Bank in Park Street) have gone. The bin that used to be visible from the Rectory Lane churchyard entrance has been moved to a hidden, side position which is no longer visible either to those walking through the churchyard or to car park users in the Rectory Lane carpark.
I think many dog owners would agree that yet again Woodstock Town Council has taken its eye off actual balls, to focus on imaginary ones. It was quite wrong to let a new official from Publica decide where to remove bins in Woodstock without any public consultation and without a discussion in the Town Council.
This matters not only because the amount of dog poo left around the Town has not only increased but an absence of visible bins encourages some irresponsible dog owners to believe that they can get away with fouling the neighbourhood. There is an abundance of evidence of this all round the Town.
We should restore the missing 21 bins, even increase the number where needed. There should be zero tolerance of fouling by dogs and Woodstock Town Council must now show they take this matter seriously.
Yours,
Anthony Glees
Letter - Tony Gardiner - Apr 2023
Dear Editor,
May I, through WOBL express my thanks to a very kind group of people who came to my aid on Friday 3rd March in Blenheim Park.
After what is now assumed to be an adverse reaction to medication, I fainted whilst walking and was 'out; on the ground for around 10 seconds. When I 'came around' I was encircled by a group of caring and concerned strangers.
After the most gentle of instruction not to move and sympathetic questioning to establish if I had sustained any injury and test for lucidity they ultimately helped me to my feet.
The spirit of care was further extended when one of the group, a charming lady named Karen (the only name I know) insisted she drive me home. She went to the car park, returned with her car and not only took me home but came in and explained what had happened to my wife.
It is reassuring and refreshing to know that the spirit of community and concern for others is, despite sentiment in some quarters to the contrary, alive and flourishing in Woodstock.
My sincere and grateful thanks to all those who stopped and gave me support and assistance on Friday.
Yours faithfully,
Tony Gardiner open letter sent 12 March 2023
Letter - Robert McGurrin - Apr 2023
Dear Dominic Hare, of Blenheim Palace, Objection to Botley West Proposed Solar Farm Although we are aware that the Blenheim Estate is a large profit making business and as such needs to find new ways to continue to profit in order to continue to maintain the palace. Nevertheless, this proposed project covering 3,500 acres in VWHDC, WODC, and Cherwell DC is beyond the pale, overpowering, antienvironmental and the supposed benefits will never match the cost of building this monstrosity, maintaining it, and protecting it from vandalism.
Locally, Woodstock will definitely be among the areas to be negatively impacted as well as all these councils, Bladon, Begbroke, Cassington, Cumnor, Eynsham, Hanborough, Yarnton and Woodstock.
Your Prime Minister's reaction to solar farms is, 'On my watch we will not lose swathes of our best farmland to solar farms. Instead, we should be making sure that solar panels are installed on commercial buildings, on sheds and properties. With the hundreds of houses that you and Pye are building many solar panels should be erected on the roofs, instead, acres of needed farmland will be wasted in a time of high food prices and scarcity. It is incomprehensible until one realises what a magnet money is to some people. It will be a shining monument to Blenheim for the next 40 years and when it has served its purpose, this enormous glass menagerie will most likely become a huge housing development. People come and go but the Blenheim Estate lives on forever 75% of this prohibitive project will be on green belt land and impacts UNESCO World Heritage Sites of Oxford, Blenheim itself and even Churchill cannot sleep in peace. WAG supports STOP BOTLEY WEST Campaign.
Sincerely yours,
Dr Robert W. McGurrin Chair of Woodstock Action Group (WAG)
Letter - Stan Scott - Apr 2023
Dear Editor,
Without notice or consultation, huge changes have been made to the Stagecoach buses in Woodstock. The 7 and 233 services have been combined into the S7, a double decker bus now travelling from Witney to Bladon roundabout, up into Woodstock and turning in the town, occasionally visiting the school and Hensington before returning to Bladon roundabout and on into Oxford via Parkway and Summertown. Fewer buses come to Old Woodstock, and the bus turnaround at the first Wootton turn is now just an expensive eyesore, a real mess.
Oxfordshire County Council seem not to have kept our County Councillor or Town Councillor informed, but now say: "Stagecoach have registered a route to use public roads around Woodstock town centre and we are not able to prevent them from doing so. A key part of ensuring commercial viability is to generate additional trips which would not have been made on the 7 and 233, for example Hanborough to Oxford. Diverting to Old Woodstock would take longer and put people off, travelling on a longer section of road twice on each journey." My thanks to my near neighbour Mick Onions for getting this statement by writing in. Other Old Woodstock neighbours wonder how to get to hospital appointments by bus, a taxi can cost £40.
I have been told we can make our views known at the Town Meeting on 18th April. or bus users and other affected could have their own mass meeting at the Town Hall or the Youth Club?
Stan Scott
Letter - Graham Brown - May 2023
Dear Readers
**Continuity, Advice and Progress.
As you may be aware, I have been asked by the editor to report on Woodstock Town Council meetings for the readers of this magazine. I try to report in an unbiased way with the information I have available but I wanted to add my own opinions of the recent meeting this time, here in the letters section.
I noticed in this meeting in particular a lack of continuity leading to a lack of progress over a number of matters. It seems if there is no councillor driving the discussion then there is a real possibility of it being lost over time.
Regarding my own submission in the public speaking session, I think to say the project for solar panels on the Community Centre is 'on hold' is rather missing the point of the Climate Emergency. I was hoping the council would lead the way on 'solar for roofs not farmland' campaign bearing in mind their support of the Stop Botley West Solar. Solar panels for the Community Centre have been discussed at council for over 10 years, when government support would have meant the panels would have been paid for by now. If the council wishes to include a section on its website entitled Climate Emergency, I believe they should act on their words.
The lack of both a permanent town clerk and the acknowledgement of previous council meetings decisions has meant many projects are being delayed including action on bus shelters, a 20mph limit through town and Community Centre solar.
One other thing that other members of the public commented to me about in this meeting was the council's unwillingness to ask for help or advice on subjects they have little or no experience. The Risk Register was an example where the ability to carry out a risk assessment was lacking but only after much discussion a councillor suggested getting help from outside of the council. To me it is perfectly reasonable to seek advice or training to acquire the skills for council business - after all our councillors are volunteers and cannot know everything. It would save so much time.
Graham Brown
Letter - Tom Wiater - May 2023
Dear Readers,
Amidst a time of environmental crisis, I was elated to hear that Europe's biggest solar farm was being planned not far from my house in Woodstock.
Although we are a long way forward to zero carbon production, it's indisputable that Botley West will make a profound impact on the world's attitude to climate change. It will create a domino effect of action against climate change. There will be more solar farms, more offshore wind turbines and more eco-friendly travel.
I was appalled and frustrated by the many signs I have seen rejecting the Botley West plan, how can these individuals be so egocentrically bullheaded? We need to act now! It's completely beside the point whether or not we will be the ones reaping the energy from the solar panels. There's a Greek proverb which sums up this situation perfectly:'A society grows great when old men plant trees, the shade of which they know they will never sit in' Whether we will be around to see the progress that has been made, we owe it to the planet. It's our moral responsibility whether we like it or not. The longer we delay action, the more severe and irreversible the consequences will be.
Climate change is causing irreversible damage to our ecosystems, species, and communities. The melting of glaciers and ice caps, rising sea levels, and increased frequency of extreme weather events are all leading to the loss of biodiversity, displacement of people, and destruction of coastal infrastructure. It's time for such large scale action to justifiably be our number one priority.
Please, we need a greener future for our greatgrandchildren's grandchildren.
Tom Wiater, aged 17
Letter - Robert Edwards - May 2023
Dear Readers,
In recent years Woodstock Town Council has paid for the streets to be sprayed with weed killer twice a year . This is no longer possible since the chemicals are now considered to be harmful to insect life and consequently to pollination.
Grass and weeds are sprouting enthusiastically on Woodstock's streets.
His Majesty King Charles has invited us to support voluntary projects on Bank Holiday Monday 8th May following the Coronation. May I suggest that we all weed our streets for thirty minutes on that day? The central area is in particular need of love and attention.
Robert Edwards
Letter - Andy Graham - June 2023
Dear Editor,
Three issues pertinent to Woodstock and Bladon have arisen over recent months and longer. By the time you read this the new parking arrangement will have been operating a short while and of course we are hoping to see improvements in terms of business churn and less illegal parking and proper enforcement undertaken on our streets in the centre of Woodstock. Remember free parking continues in the main car parks operated by West Oxfordshire District Council and there is the first hour in the on street parking zones in the centre of the town but don't forget to get your ticket and display it clearly. I know how controversial this has been but on balance this should work better for most people and residents too who have the option of applying for a residents parking permit.
It will take a little while to bed in and we will be monitoring how ell the scheme work and will make some adjustments if necessary.
The bus turning in the centre of the town is considered by many a pedestrian safety issue and I couldn't agree more but we need to see the results of the safety audit which has been done together with evidence accumulated by residents before a final decision is made. Pleased to see the petition and I support that being presented to Council in Oxford demonstrating the strength of feeling on the matter.
Speed limit reductions from 30mph to 20 mph has been out to consultation and I am pleased with the response to date and feel pleased the town council has undertaken this exercise and this will be considered at OCC. Once again , pedestrian safety and that means children walking to school safely is of paramount importance. The results of the consultation and the scheme will be considered by the cabinet member for highways in due course for determination and if approved scheduled to be done.
Kind regards to all of you who I represent.
Cllr Andy Graham
Letter - Bob McGurrin - June 2023
Dear Editor,
There has been a lot of talk recently, most of it negative, concerning the Blenheim Estate's and Merton College's proposal to build a supergigantic solar farm: deceptively called Botley West. I gave a talk, representing WAG, at the Woodstock Annual Town Meeting on 18 April 2023.
But first, let me shine a bright light upon a new unexpected twist in the testing tale of the industrialised Botley West I was advised by the 'Stop Botley West' group to get a copy of the May 2023 issue of' Private Eye'. But the newsagent was sold out and it wasn't until later that I found out why. There is an article in it called Marlborough light about the Botley West Solar Farm, and those associated with it: the Blenheim Estate (the Spencer -Churchill Family), Merton College, and Photovolt Development Partners. The latter company is accused of being 'backed by some seriously dubious Russian money'.
Naturally, the entire article cannot be reprinted here but the gist is that it exposes Photovolt Partners as being among a number of companies, in a New York court case last year, and that a Russian company, GK Amazarkan,was said to conceal money and be syphoning off assets to lo and behold, Photovolt Development Partners GmBH and Cransetta Investments. This is the company, in partnership with Blenheim Estate and Merton College, that is expected to build a sprawling Solar farm on 3,500acres of land including Woodstock when, although it claims scores of solar developments, it only refers to just one such in Japan, still not finished and of which, Photovolt sold out in 2018.
I read each copy of Private Eye and can attest that their reporters certainly do their homework. Let's face it, in my opinion, Photovolt Partners are not fit for purpose and have cast a shadow of complicity and associative contamination upon their cohorts in this preposterous proposal by the Blenheim Estate and Merton College. How will they react to these incriminating statements? To be continued.
Bob McGurrin WAG (Woodstock Action Group)
In response, here is a statement from Photovolt Development Partners, sent from the CEO of Blenheim: The proposals for Botley West Solar Farm - a nationally significant renewable energy scheme Ð are being progressed in compliance with relevant UK legislation and guidance. This includes undertaking thorough consultation and environmental impact assessment.
SolarFive Ltd, the owner of Botley West Solar Farm, is licensed by Ofgem as an electricity generator and due diligence was undertaken on all individuals involved when the decision to grant this license was being considered. Accounts and shareholders for PVDP's five UK limited companies are available for all to view on the Companies House website.
Botley West Solar Farm is being funded by the proceeds of the sale of PVDP's projects in Japan. Robust checks and balances are in place throughout the Development Consent Order process, including the requirement to provide a Funding Statement with our DCO application, detailing the corporate and financial arrangements of the Applicant.'
Letter - Themis Avraamides - June 2023
Dear Editor,
I would like to provide an update on the ludicrous situation with regard to the double decker Stagecoach buses using the town centre as a roundabout.
First, a huge thank you to the almost 500 people who kindly signed the petition to restrict the buses in the town centre - it demonstrates the breadth and depth of anger and indignation understandably felt about the decision by Stagecoach to ignore the purpose built (tax payer funded) Wootton turning point down the road, purely to save them 3 minutes each way (thereby also depriving Old Woodstock of a much needed service).
Armed with this hefty petition, we spoke to Andy Graham who agreed with our view having witnessed the situation first hand, and a process was set in motion to request the OCC to impose a TRO (traffic regulatory order) to restrict the buses from using the town centre as a roundabout. Stagecoach head office have been extremely belligerent and have been looking for ways to force their route through the town centre.
On Tuesday 16th May, I presented the petition and made a presentation to the full OCC annual council meeting at Oxford County Hall, where I made the relevant points, focusing particularly on the health and safety dangers due to the inappropriate size of the buses, getting regularly stuck in the square (and illegally reversing) due to normal traffic, as well as the legally parked and necessary delivery vans serving half a dozen businesses in the square, and the dangers posed by bus wing mirrors overhanging the pavement - in brief, they are a danger and a nuisance on many levels.
The presentation was well received and consequently an independent health and safety audit was commissioned by the OCC - they attended on Friday 19th and 20th May. Several of us spoke to them on these days, and it became very evident to them on both days that there is indeed a problem posed by the buses - the buses obliged by getting stuck, reversing and generally causing mayhem in the square in full view of the safety auditors. Indeed, one took a bus ride to see for himself and found himself duly stuck on the bus which then had to reverse (illegally) in the square and off load passengers. One of the officials also personally timed the drive to the Wootton turning point at 3 minutes each way - we are very grateful to the independent health and safety auditors who were observant and diligent.
We now wait for their report to be sent to the OCC, whose decision we expect towards the mid / end of June.
Themis Avraamides, LLB, MBA
Letter - Bob McGurrin - Aug 2023
Dear Editor,
In last month's issue, I cited an article in the May 2023 issue of Private Eye, 'Marlborough Light' which claimed that the company in charge of running the proposed preposterous Botley West Solar Farm, Photovolt Development Partners, 'is backed by some seriously dubious Russian money.' The Blenheim Estate and Merton College, Oxford are partners with this shady company-based in Germany but the owner of it, a Yulia Lezhen is also known as Julia LeJeune, a Russian who lives in Cyprus. She is the wife of Dmitry Glukhov, who is allegedly accused, in a N.Y. court case, of borrowing money for a goldfield in Russia which, apparently never was developed and using money 'sifted' from Photovolt Partners Ltd. and Solar Five Ltd., whose ownership was transferred from a Cyprus Company, Cransetta Investments Ltd. (Y. Lezhen boss) to Peter Gertsmann, Director, a German and a Julia LeJeune, an alternate name of Y. Lezhen. Photovolt would not explain the reason for the name switch. Mr. Gertsmann lives in the U.K. He is also Director of 5 other companies dealing with Solar Energy.
Well, Private Eye has continued its assault on the bamboozled Botley West Solar farm fiasco in its 30June/13July issue (no.1601) in an article, 'Light and shady' in which it reiterated that Solar Five Ltd., the company associated with Photovolt 'is backed by dubious Russian money.' It has filed a 140 page 'scoping report'. What is a 'scoping report'? Succinctly put, it is a statement that defines all the elements of the project scope as well as all of the assumptions, project requirements and acceptance. The length of this report is 140 pages when a scope statement does not have to be to be long -most can be done well in a page or two. (google) It's my experience that some companies present voluminous scoping reports hoping to deter as many people from reading them! It seems, according to Private Eye, that the Blenheim Finance Ltd.'s Company borrowings are in a perilous state of affairs: hence the pressing need for much profit from the Botley West Solar Farm project.
The government regulator Ofgen has been notified by MP Robert Courts of the Solar Five and Photovolts's finances marked by dubious transactions. WAG plans to do the same. Stay tuned.
Bob McGurrin
Letter - Linda Addis - Aug 2023
Dear Editor,
On the New parking restrictions Since the new system has been in place there has been a lot of comments. I know we all have our own opinion on this subject but as I work in the post office and am also a representative on the WTC I feel I should pass on their comments.
Some of the comments as follows:
- Why is it when business owners are unloading their vehicles they get parking tickets?
- There is still not a turn around
- Footfall has gone down for a lot only a few has increased
- People from outside the town do not come to town because they don't want to pay for parking
- Where do employees park? Some have to pay for parking when doing voluntary work
- Business owners were not asked about the new parking system
- Why don't we have a one way system round the town? I feel a lot of residents have said the same. Woodstock
Town Centre will not be the same in one year's time because shops will be closed and it will all be residential.
This is very sad. The reason why I have written in to the Woodstock and Bladon News is because I have listened and thought I would pass people's comments on.
A lot of residents have also said that whatever the council decide it gets turned the other way.
Linda Addis
Letter - Carolyn Quincey - Sept 2023
Dear Editor,
We enjoy all the articles and information. Your food editor's columns are always good reading and we love to try the venues out for ourselves! Last Friday we had the pleasure of going to Brothertons. It was a beautiful evening so we sat at a table on the cobbles and decided to copy Dai Roberts and have the same menu (even down to the wine). What a great choice! We remarked that it felt like being on holiday. Oh, and we got the 10% discount which went straight back to them as part of the reward for an excellent meal and service.
Best wishes, Carolyn Quincey
Letter - Sharone Parnes - Sept 2023
Dear Editor,
Woodstock Town Council has formally resolved to become a signatory of a petition by Woodstock's parliamentary representative, Mr Robert Courts, MP. The petition 'declares that the large scale solar farm application known as 'Botley West Solar Farm' is detrimental to the local community, notes that its scale and design are incompatible with the current infrastructure of the area; further declares that preservation of farmland for food security, local amenity, rural character and green belt preservation must take precedence when considering solar farm applications.' It is anticipated that the petition will be presented at proceedings in the House of Commons after the summer recess, to be formally put on record and require a Government response.
Full wording of the petition, with further explanation of the reason for it, is available online at: https:// www.robertcourts.co.uk/botleysolarfarmpetition . It can be signed online. Woodstock Town Council's decision, to sign it, was determined by named vote at its extraordinary town council meeting on August 8th.
The petition is said to be intended to help our MP 'reflect the scale of opinion to the Government, thereby ensuring they take this into consideration when the final decision is made by the Secretary of State.' I very much hope the town council's decision will be helpful in encouraging individuals and other councils to consider signing it, too.
Sharone Parnes Town Councillor for Woodstock
Letter - Gwyn Bevan - Sept 2023
Dear Editor,
Is Botley West Solar the best option for our climate crisis? What has been happening this summer makes previous discussions of the 'threats' of 'global warming' or 'climate change', and a net-zero target for 2050 look as out of date as a pony and trap. We are experiencing 'global boiling'. As the ###Letter in the August edition of Woodstock & Bladon News from the Sustainable Woodstock steering group rightly pointed out 'the climate crisis is the defining crisis of our time'. An article by Peter and Susanne Ditlevsen published this July modelled the threat of the gulf stream collapsing[1]. That would mean that our climate would be like Canada's, and bring catastrophic consequences for India, South America and West Africa; and further endanger the Amazon rainforest and Antarctic ice sheets. The gloomiest prediction of the collapse of the gulf stream was just two years away. So, is the proposed development of the Botley West solar farm needed more than when we first learnt of that in the Autumn of last year? For me, that proposal, raises three questions.
First, is solar the best choice given the immediate impact of manufacturing the technology needed is to add greenhouse gases (GHGs) to the atmosphere? To answer that question we need to know the GHG emissions generated per kilowatt-hour for each technology over its total life cycle Ð that includes production, installation, operation and decommissioning. The National Renewable Energy Laboratory (of the US Department of Energy Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy) undertook a systematic review of 3,000 published life cycle assessment studies of various forms of electricity generation. They found 'from cradle to grave, coal- fired electricity releases about 20 times more GHGs than solar, wind, or nuclear electricity'. But they also found that land and off-shore wind produce much fewer GHGs than Photovoltaic per kilowatt-hour.[2] Second, why develop one of the biggest solar farms in the world in one of the countries that is the least propitious for the generation of solar energy? The World Bank shows Britain's relative lack of sunshine means that it is one of the worst places in the world for Solar Photovoltaic Power Potential.[3] Britain is a great place for generating green energy powered by wind.
Third, why is the government looking to private finance of green technology when the government can always borrow more cheaply than any private investor? Regulating privatised green energy generation looks more problematic than regulation of privatised water and sewage, and we know how that has turned out.
Gwyn Bevan
[1] Ditlevsen, P., Ditlevsen, S. Warning of a forthcoming collapse of the Atlantic meridional overturning circulation Nature Communication 14, 4254 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-023-39810-w [2] National Renewable Energy Laboratory Life Cycle Greenhouse Gas Emissions from Electricity Generation: Update https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy21osti/80580.pdf [3] World Bank (2020) Solar Photovoltaic Power Potential by Country https://www.worldbank.org/en/topic/energy/publication/solar-photovoltaic-powerpotential-by-country
Letter - Graham Brown - Oct 2023
Dear Editor
In response to Mr Bevan's letter in your September issue, 'Is Botley West Solar the best option for our climate crisis?' I would like to add a few points for thought and hopefully balance. As Mr Bevan rightly says, we are now experiencing 'global boiling' and the climate crisis is suddenly looking very immediate and very real. He then raises three questions.
Firstly, is solar the best choice given the greenhouse gases emitted on manufacture? I just wanted to give the figures from the report that was cited (1). Most of the fossil fuel now used in our power stations is gas, which from the National Renewable Energy Report has a value of 486 - total life cycle greenhouse gas units. In comparison solar is 43 and wind (the figure used land-based and offshore combined) is 13. I absolutely support offshore (and onshore) wind but due to the emergency we are now facing, I and others suggest we need both wind and solar in our energy mix, these are the main tools we have to generate renewable energy. Furthermore, there are a number of reports about the National Grid struggling to incorporate offshore wind energy and that many of the best sites for offshore wind (shallow water) are already being used. Floating wind turbines for use in deeper water are still being developed. Also, government policy regarding licensing offshore windfarms has not helped. A Guardian article from 8th September reports 'no new offshore wind farms were secured in the government's latest clean energy auction'. This was due to the pricing level set too low and no doubt will be negotiated but it provides further delay and highlights the need for multiple approaches to address the need to generate renewable energy to reduce carbon emissions. Wind and solar are currently our best way to generate renewable energy and the figures from the NREL report are still over 10x less for solar compared to gas.
Secondly, regarding the World Bank report (2), this is a long and detailed report (and actually quite interesting) that attempts to shed light for policymakers and businesses on whether a specific country meets the right criteria to take advantage of solar power. Yes, the UK is second from bottom on the ranking of the potential of countries to generate solar power but the report later states 'even in countries with lower solar resource availability, the potential is not dramatically lower compared to the top-performing group.' It continues, 'the results presented in this report show that the global range of photovoltaic electricity potential is not as wide as might be expected. The difference between the countries with the highest and lowest average potential is only slightly higher than a factor of 2.' Furthermore, the high relative price of electricity in the UK coupled with the dramatic fall in cost of PV panels over the last 10 years, makes solar PV economically competitive, this is why we see solar farms and panels on roofs in this country. The report continues 'despite higher seasonability and lower PV potential, solar PV may still be a profitable option, playing an important role in the energy mix along with other energy sources' As an aside, from a global climate crisis viewpoint the report finishes 'there is a unique opportunity for solar PV to provide affordable, reliable and sustainable electricity to a large share of humanity where improved economic opportunities and quality of life are most needed'. For example, Mexico would need to dedicate only around 0.1% of its territory to large scale solar PV power plants to cover its entire yearly electricity consumption. Let us hope world leaders respond to the opportunity.
Mr Bevan's third point I absolutely agree with, the generation of green energy should be government led (if not a nonpolitical group) and in fairness it is trying with a number of initiatives, such as green guilts and bonds to fund green energy development. Why the majority of the new houses being built around the country do not have solar panels continues to amaze me. If the government could achieve large renewable energy projects quickly, efficiently and to budget then great, but as first alluded at the start of his ###Letter, this is a real emergency and we need to reduce our carbon emissions now, be it with public or private finance. We cannot afford to wait.
Graham Brown
Letter - Jo Lamb - Oct 2023
Dear Editor
Your readers may have noticed that Stagecoach's buses are no longer using Woodstock town centre as a turning point.
There used to be some 66 buses undertaking this unsafe manoeuvre every day, starting from about 5am and ending in the early hours of the following morning.
As a result of local opposition, over 500 signatories to a local Petition, as well as pressure being exerted by our local County Councillor Andy Graham, the County Council arranged for an independent Safety Report on the bus turning route to be obtained. This duly reported back to the County Council that it was dangerous to public safety at all times, for buses to be turning in Market Square. The Report also recommended that buses should revert to using Wootton Turn to do this throughout the entire day.
Stagecoach then argued that for some reason, it was merely more dangerous between 9am and 5pm but that before and after these times, the town centre bus turnaround was somehow 'safe'.
It was obvious to many of us that commercial considerations were being used by Stagecoach as its argument to trump the needs of public safety here. This surely could never be allowed by the Authorities? Considerations of public safety had to be made paramount.
However, both unfortunately but also fortuitously, there was a bus accident within Woodstock. A Stagecoach bus late one evening, ran into the former Nat' West Bank building in Market Square, narrowly missing several people who had been enjoying their weekend pints outside the Star. This was also a scary experience for passengers inside the bus, who sustained minor cuts and bruises and who were tearful and shaken by the incident. Matters could have been so much worse. Someone could have been seriously injured or even killed.
At last, Stagecoach conceded to common sense as well as local public and County Council pressure. This is where we now are. The bus company has voluntarily agreed to revert to turning buses slightly further along the A44 and using the purpose built Wootton Turn as it had previously done. An added bonus of this arrangement is that Old Woodstock should no longer miss out on its S7 service altogether.
So far, so good! However, we only have a voluntary agreement in place at this point. Stagecoach could change the arrangement whenever it wishes to. This is why legislative backing has to be obtained next, by means of a TRO (Traffic Regulation Order), prohibiting Stagecoach from turning buses within Woodstock. This TRO it would seem, can only be made by the Traffic Commissioner at Ministry of Transport level. This will be a complicated procedure which will take time. There is every likelihood that Stagecoach will challenge the need for the TRO, which will then involve Tribunal proceedings, presided over by a Traffic Commissioner. Our County and District Councils will also be involved (and probably also Estelle Manor), because of the S106 subsidies to the new route.
The current saga will continue until such time that the recent voluntary arrangement with Stagecoach becomes mandatory. This is the next critical stage. This must be the aim and the County Council's next battle In the meantime we can all enjoy the absence of large buses turning around in Market Square, as well as the reinstatement of the S7 service for Old Woodstock residents. Happily this is a victory for common sense and public safety.
Kind regards,
Jo Lamb
(Please note: I write this in my personal capacity and not as a local Town Councillor)
Letter - Stan Scott - Nov 2023
Dear Editor,
A battle lost
The battle to stop the building of 180 houses to the north of Woodstock is lost. The Planning Inspectorate has granted Blenheim's appeal against the District Council's refusal of planning permission to build on an open field behind Hill Rise in Old Woodstock.
The only way to town from there is by the busy A44 main road, for pedestrians, cyclists and motorists. Hundreds more family members will have to walk on the dangerous A44 pavements, with 'pinch points' where heavy vehicles and buses pass very close to each other and to pedestrians.
In addition, there is the despoiling of a splendid area of countryside with views over towards Wootton, Sturdy's Castle and Rousham in one direction, and towards Blenheim Palace and Park and the church tower in the other. The Campaign for the Protection of Old Woodstock (C-POW), a group of Old Woodstock residents, has worked tirelessly for several years to put forward the objections to this unwanted development and have been congratulated by the Town Council who also made strong objection.
The expensive King's Counsel and planning experts lined up by Blenheim can seldom have faced such well-researched, detailed and measured reasoning from the C-POW team. Blenheim's application for costs has only partly been met.
Woodstock will be a mess, it seems, with this and the other large development off Banbury Road making a tangle for traffic looking for ways to get around: Shipton Road, the Hensington estate and through the narrow lane adjacent to The Punchbowl.
Thank goodness that the buses no longer turn in the town. Incidentally, we hear that the Town Council is considering asking the County Council to make a traffic regulation order, banning buses for all time. Of course, occasional tourist buses bring trade, so we only want to ban 'service' buses on a regular route from the town, and Stagecoach will see this as a direct attack when it has already done what we asked and sent the buses up to the Wootton turn. We need the buses in Old Woodstock, and the County Council needs the co-operation and goodwill of Stagecoach. I do hope that buses do not go into the new Hill Rise estate, another potential source of danger.
Stan Scott
Letter - Bob McGurrin - Nov 2023
Dear Editor,
Why I strongly object to the proposed preposterous Botley West Solar Farm (BWSF) First of all, it is obvious to all that solar farms do not operate on a continual basis, i.e., at night, during overcast, rainy, snowy, stormy, misty, and foggy days. E.g., in Oxford, Clouds- from the 14 October until about the 8th of April are the cloudier months of the year. So, BWSF would be generating less energy during these darker months. Rainfall-From 27 May to 3 February are the wettest months. November, with a chance of 32%, is the month with the most rain. So, BWSF would experience still less generative days or none at all. However, climate change may exacerbate these conditions for the worse.
But looking on the bright side, we see that sunlight, i.e., the length of a day, is, throughout the year, variable with the longest day in Oxford in June and the shortest in December. BWSF would generate variably also Solar Energy: From 26 October to 26 February is the darker period of the year when average solar energy is less than 1.8 kilowatts per square meter. Thus, negatively affecting electricity generation from BWSF, if ever built. Severe named winter storms of amber or red warnings, average 7.3 per year since 1916. So, it is quite evident that solar farms produce electricity at the whim of weather.
No matter what the developers claim that BWSF will produce enough electricity for 300,000 homes, BWSF will not produce 840 megawatts of energy for 24 hours a day, seven days a week. In fact, it will, according to electrical engineers, remain dormant most of the day and rarely reach full generation. (Dan Way, 'Solar Energy output ratings misleading if not deceptive', critics say) So I ask that government officials who stand to approve or disapprove BWSF, realise that the 840 megawatts claimed will not be a steady flow of electricity.
Although rather easy to maintain and clean, BWSF will need an expensive back up system, probably electric, to click in instantly when power is interrupted by clouds, rainfall or other weather phenomena Then there are thieves and vandals about. Based in rural areas and unmanned, BWSF will be an easy target for thieves dealing in valuable solar panels, copper wiring and cables.
Vandalism, either of protest or boys throwing rocks to break panels will take place on this vast BSSF, and will need very expensive security systems to cover 3,400 acres of solar panels. Costs will certainly keep mounting. But what about profits for the instigators of this momentous plan?
Dr Bob McGurrin
Letter - Hilary Brown - Dec 2023
Dear Editor,
**Keeping positive and hopeful as climate change knocks on our door
If you missed the recent event Clean Energy, Why Here & Why Now Eco-hosted by Sustainable Woodstock and Sian Godwin (the editor of this magazine) I really recommend you view it on YouTube (subtitles included). https:// youtu.be/ULkyDLThKQE?t=242 or search Woodstock Energy Event.
The proposal for such a large solar farm in our area came as a complete surprise to everyone É but should it really have been such a surprise? The world is trying to lower greenhouse gases to safe levels as quickly as possible but sadly, the recent progress report showed just how far behind we are in our ambitions.
By the time you read this, the COP28 will be in session in UAE, where representatives from nearly 200 countries attempt to coordinate global climate action for the next year. The panellists who gave their support to the 'Clean Energy, Why Here & Why Now' event work in different aspects of climate science with a knowledge base that is both global and local. They were there to help us better understand the science and the facts by answering questions posed by the audience related to the proposed Botley West Solar Farm.
Listening to their answers and comments on 'why here and why now' was clear, comprehensive and helpful and it seems clear that we should direct our questions, suggestions or requests for community benefits, biodiversity gain, local amenity and much more to the developers and landowners during the next phase of the consultation which runs from December through to February.
Whether you agree or disagree with the proposal you are still able to put pressure on the developers to create a solar farm with the best possible outcome, and it should include a significant community benefit package as seen in other solar/wind projects. If we don't engage then we will lose an important opportunity. Yes, the proposal is big and needs all stakeholders to work together and not be so polarised (as one audience-member put it), to achieve a WIN-WIN for the planet, people and nature.
Sustainable Woodstock have been consistent in our message. We recognise that the UK is way behind where we should be in renewable energy generation and in the development of an effective national and local grid. The climate crisis is now so severe and the consequences expected to be so catastrophic that we feel obliged to support, in principle, the planning application for Botley West Solar Farm.
We hope you'll be at the Festive Fayre at St Mary Magdalene's ,sharing your ideas on community benefits and protecting nature with us. We need to be sure we include community benefits in the plans, as well ideas to mitigate the effects of climate warming. If the proposal doesn't go ahead - what have you lost? If the proposal does go ahead, let's make sure our voices are heard?
Hilary Brown
Letter - Ann Leggett - Dec 2023
Dear Editor,
I just would like to thank the organisers of the excellent meeting last Thursday on 'Clean Energy - Why Here? Why Now?' Each of the experts was articulate and knowledgeable and I learned so much from them all. Although they were well received by many who were there, I only wish I thought that more people in the audience were persuaded by what they heard.
Many thanks,
Ann Leggett